Must a mediator be a lawyer? Skills, law and a changing profession | Episode 2

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri and Daniel Harush discuss mediation skills, legal roles, public awareness and career expectations. This detailed edited guide follows the complete available Hebrew source, a conversation anticipating January2021 reform during COVID. Both originals are in Hebrew; chapter times refer to the transcript, not synchronized translated captions.

Original Hebrew video

Watch on YouTube

Original Hebrew audio

Listen on Spotify

0:16 — A second episode, and the people behind it

Daniel Harush introduces Nadav Nishri. Smoothies, espresso, good company and many topics set the scene. They thank Noga for filming and support and Sharon Kaniel for sound and the technical environment, joking about the cables. This is a conversation between two mediators, not a professional-licensing examination.

1:07 — Are you also a lawyer?

Daniel says people almost immediately ask whether he is a lawyer when he introduces himself as a mediator. He is not. He asks why two different approaches became linked in public understanding. Mediation requires conflict and process skills; being a lawyer alone does not establish those skills. Particular appointments and activities can nevertheless carry legal qualification requirements.

2:09 — Harvard’s contribution, not the invention of all mediation

Nadav recalls Roger Fisher, William Ury and Getting to Yes, separating people from problems and interests from positions. Harvard’s own history dates its Negotiation Project to 1979 and the book to 1981, also recognizing Bruce Patton. These are important developments in modern negotiation, not evidence that every form of mediation originated in a single law department.

2:44 — Frank Sander and a choice of processes

They mention the Pound Conference and Frank Sander’s multi-door courthouse: match people with negotiation, mediation, litigation, arbitration or another suitable route. Harvard identifies Sander’s 1976 speech and Chief Justice Burger’s role. The point is an appropriate choice, not that one door must replace all the others. Daniel interrupts to ask why courts wanted alternatives.

3:03 — Pressure on courts, and a stronger claim than the evidence

Nadav describes growing caseloads, frustration and dissatisfaction driving interest in alternatives. He goes further, saying courts do not work anywhere in the Western world. That is his emphatic criticism, not a demonstrated global conclusion. Courts also protect rights and decide matters that cannot safely or lawfully be settled by a private conversation.

3:51 — Community disputes, neighbors and divorce

He describes mediation spreading through community services and neighbor disputes, then divorce, where continuing parenting makes the future especially important. He invokes research without identifying studies. Agreement may help where suitable; it is not invariably better in every case, and a litigant is not inevitably worse off. Safety, power, consent, enforceability and needed remedies still matter.

4:39 — The child and master image, and success percentages

Nadav imagines mediation as a child outperforming its legal parent and questions the system’s preference for more judicial posts. He mentions 70–80% success in general mediation and more in divorce. No dataset, definition of success or selection method is supplied; these are recording-era claims, not a verified forecast for a reader’s dispute or proof of professional motives.

5:35 — Trust and political explanations

Daniel raises what he sees as declining public trust, while acknowledging an argument that political attacks on the judiciary contribute. They avoid making this a party-political episode and ask whether procedural experience also matters. No particular survey series is identified. Their discussion cannot determine the relative causes or establish current trust levels.

6:14 — Nadav’s first law-class story

Nadav remembers a constitutional-law lecturer asking what the High Court of Justice does. A student answered justice; the lecturer sharply contrasted law and justice and staged a moment of silence. This is his personal recollection and teaching anecdote, not an official definition that courts have no concern for fairness. The student’s identity is unnecessary to its point.

7:26 — The conversation he recalls with Meni Mazuz

Nadav also recounts asking Meni Mazuz about justice and hearing an emphasis on applying the law enacted by the legislature. The guide does not independently authenticate that exchange or present it as a quotation establishing judicial policy. Its theme is the gap between expectations of personal vindication and what a legal decision can deliver.

7:47 — Paperwork, delay and an unmet expectation

He describes outdated working habits, large pleadings, bureaucracy and cases taking two or three years, sometimes twenty. These examples express his criticism, not a duration estimate for every court. The internet and changing life make procedural improvement important; necessary representation, urgent relief and legal deadlines should not be abandoned because a process may be slow.

8:43 — Third-person help existed long before Harvard

Daniel points to village elders and rabbis: people have long asked others to help them talk. This corrects an overly narrow origin story. Older authority-based intervention and modern consensual mediation are not automatically identical. A mediator can assist the process while participants retain the decision, rather than replacing one imposed authority with another.

9:10 — Authority, experience and reputation

They contrast trust in a community elder with confidence built through a mediator’s education, practice, experience and reputation when community ties are weaker. Credentials alone do not ensure competence, and reputation alone does not prove suitability. Ask about the actual role, training, conflicts, process and the advice needed for the particular dispute.

9:36 — The familiar professional and the invisible alternative

Daniel explicitly says he has no figures for his impression that people first think of a lawyer and a claim. Nadav imagines asking an ordinary resident of Hadera how many mediators she knows: perhaps none, one or two, versus many lawyers. It is a visibility example, not a survey or proof about that resident.

10:30 — Cost is a question to compare, not a guaranteed knockout

Nadav says mediation wins on every parameter, mentioning NIS 400 per party per hour and court fees he recalls as 1.5–2%, plus lawyers and time. These are historical examples, not current prices or universal fee rules. Compare written scope, tax, duration, advice and implementation costs; neither savings nor agreement is guaranteed. An official 2017 announcement concerned a specific post-MAHUT fee setting, not every private mediator’s rate.

11:16 — Institutional criticism and the comfortable peddler image

Daniel criticizes judicial appointments and the Bar’s public controversies; these are his opinions, not proof of misconduct by every judge or lawyer. Nadav invokes Agnon’s The Lady and the Peddler as an image of comfort delaying change. His compressed retelling should not be treated as a reliable account of that story’s ending. The practical point is an incentive to remain with the familiar.

12:09 — Education costs, employment and artificial intelligence

Nadav mentions a law degree costing NIS 100,000, internship periods of one and then two years, increasing lawyer numbers and AI reducing legal work. He predicts a profession in decline. These are historical examples and forecasts, not current training rules, a labor-market study or a recommendation that no one study law. The suggested link between more lawyers and more claims is not established causation.

12:54 — Financial incentives without blaming every lawyer

He contrasts an illustrative NIS 50,000 one-sided divorce case with lower joint-mediation examples mentioning NIS 10,000 and 20,000. They are not a consistent present-day quotation or market tariff. His allegation that some professionals generate conflict to earn more expresses his experience and concern; it does not prove that every lawyer behaves that way. Independent legal advice can support informed settlement.

13:36 — Television’s dramatic picture

They mention The Good Wife and how screen drama makes trials visible while omitting much paperwork and infrequent hearings. This is a comment on professional image, not a literal account of every lawyer’s work. Choosing a career requires examining daily practice, training, costs and realistic opportunities beyond a television narrative.

13:59 — Paid exposure and unequal marketing budgets

Nadav describes paid appearances in some programs and substantial advertising, while therapists charging NIS 300–400 an hour may lack comparable resources. His reference to hundreds of millions in promotion has no supporting dataset here. It is not established that every interview or legal article is paid. Check whether content is advertising; psychological guidance and legal advice have different, potentially complementary roles.

15:13 — Do not merely wait for court referrals

Nadav says he built a private mediation practice rather than waiting for courts to provide cases. His service message was consensual discussion with potentially lower cost; his experience is not an income or demand guarantee. Court lists and referral rules are distinct from private competence, and listing can have specific education, experience and assessment requirements.

16:08 — Searching a city is not a market census

His informal check is to search for a mediator in an ordinary Israeli city. He sees lead-selling directories, including 144, and even listings for himself in places where he does not work. He interprets this as weak visibility. Search results do not establish the number or quality of practicing mediators, and a listing is not proof of a local office.

16:52 — Why not business partners too?

Daniel asks why a route successful in divorce has not spread further. He imagines business partners meeting two, three or five times and ending a dispute in one or two months rather than litigating for years. These are possibilities, not a promised schedule. Confidentiality depends on applicable rules and agreement; mediation does not ensure that nobody will know or erase reporting duties.

17:46 — The claimed decline in family claims

They refer to a fall of more than 50% in family claims and link it to awareness of mediation. They provide no comparable periods, case definition or dataset. The percentage and causal explanation are therefore not verified statistics or predictions. Their argument is that learning about a process may affect choice, not that a single reform explains all changes.

17:55 — Different professional cultures

Nadav contrasts treatment professionals entering divorce mediation with the strong legal presence in property, commercial, partnership and damages disputes. His description is not a complete census or a claim that only therapists can mediate well. Lawyers can also be skilled mediators; neither profession guarantees the ability to support voluntary, informed participant decisions.

18:32 — A named example and the garage partners

He praises Amos Gabrieli as a mediator known by word of mouth and describes a more interventionist, legally informed school of practice. He then imagines Moshe and David, garage partners, needing an accessible local mediator. Good services also need public explanation. He mentions two or three representative groups, including their voluntary organization, and a funding-and-visibility cycle; no complete organizational count is established.

19:47 — Daniel asks about government and lawmakers

Daniel returns to those who can change procedures: lawmakers and government. If they see overload, public frustration and damaged trust, why has change been slow? He first asks what actually changed before criticizing omissions. This preserves a question about institutional responsibility alongside the discussion of private initiative and marketing.

20:36 — A conversation before the January 2021 reform

The recording explicitly places itself in mid-November before 1 January 2021, during COVID. The earthquake language describes their anticipation at that time, not an upcoming change today. Nadav recalls hundreds of old procedural provisions and outdated fax-based practice. His recollection of the old rules’ dates is not used as an exact legislative history.

21:49 — Eighteen pages is not one limit for everything

Nadav expects shorter pleadings to reduce billable work and mentions an 18-page limit. Official guidance distinguishes the document, court and components, with different limits and possible judicial permission;18 is not a universal maximum. His prediction of large-scale lawyer unemployment is not a demonstrated effect of the reform. Current filing requirements need their own check, not reliance on this episode.

22:50 — Preliminary discussion and MAHUT are not forced settlement

He mentions NIS 40,000 and a preliminary discussion to narrow issues, followed by an information, assessment and coordination meeting, MAHUT. The official reform checklist describes covered claims over 40,000 in magistrates’ courts, not every civil case. Preliminary party discussion, an orientation meeting, full mediation and a signed settlement are distinct. Exceptions, actual orders and deadlines matter; a required initial step does not compel agreement.

23:28 — The family-dispute comparison

They compare the civil development with family-dispute information and assistance meetings, where participants can learn about mediation. Such meetings are not automatically a full mediation session or a duty to reconcile. Family and civil procedures have different conditions; a participant should clarify the applicable route, exceptions and protective options rather than assume every case follows the same sequence.

24:00 — What Nadav says he observed

Asked about the family reform, Nadav says its effect was not immediate: greater awareness gradually brought more inquiries. He expects a similar change in civil disputes after one or two years and hopes for growth by tens of percent. These remain his observations, hopes and recording-era forecasts, not audited outcomes, guaranteed future demand or evidence that all family lawyers will lose work.

24:38 — Offer a serious, ethical service

He wants professionals to offer mediation directly, before conflict hardens into litigation. This is not a direction to delay independent advice or protection. Establish shared future goals first, then individual needs within that basis; early personal listening is allowed. Explain competence, process, costs and limits honestly, leaving the participants free to decide whether to proceed or agree.

25:14 — Political credit and remembered opposition

Nadav credits Ayelet Shaked and then-Justice Minister Avi Nissenkorn for advancing the reform, recalling postponements under Amir Ohana and opposition associated with Bar leadership. Daniel asks whether the Bar welcomed it; Nadav recalls later support for dialogue. These are their political recollections, not a full verified chronology or proof of any person’s hidden motive. Nissenkorn is described in the role held then, not as today’s minister.

26:33 — A career question in the COVID period

Daniel asks about listeners reconsidering work, some by necessity during COVID, and whether mediation is a future profession. Nadav is enthusiastic and says he encouraged Daniel, a longstanding friend, into it. Enthusiasm and an expected two-to-four-year opportunity do not guarantee employment, limitless demand or income; qualifications and a realistic business plan need examination.

27:23 — Reputation takes years of work

Nadav warns against expecting someone else to send cases. He stresses effort, marketing, good work, word of mouth and years spent building trust. These are his practice lessons, not proof that effort always succeeds or that a lack of referrals establishes incompetence. Ethical promotion and suitable preparation matter alongside commercial initiative.

27:38 — A short course is not readiness for every case

He contrasts a 60-hour certificate with a then-free 40-hour online course he offered, saying a certificate alone will not create a practice. These are historical course examples, not a current offer or automatic recognition. Supervised practice, feedback, relevant knowledge, maturity and judgment matter; court-list criteria and specialized work require separate examination. Clients bring real lives, not an exercise to solve for them.

28:34 — Their organization and a call to cooperate

They describe their private-mediation initiative as voluntary, not an attempt to become a large public body. Nadav hopes other mediator organizations will also explain the options publicly. This invitation reflects the conversation’s original context. The point is accessible information and good service rather than merely more certificates.

29:09 — The warning he draws from Italy

Nadav recalls roughly 2,700 mediation offices appearing after an Italian reform, describing some as rebranded law offices offering narrow compromise. The count, timing and assessment are not independently verified here. They are his cautionary comparison, not current Italian law or a finding that every lawyer-mediator is inauthentic. Explain the actual approach and preserve participants’ creativity and choice, rather than promising quality through a label.

29:53 — A social hope, over a long period

Daniel wonders what these changes could mean for Israeli society, acknowledging long timescales. They hope for more dialogue and fewer battles. Growth, friendship, reconciliation and agreement are not duties. A workable process may yield cooperation, clear boundaries or respectful separation, while legal remedies remain available where needed.

30:16 — COVID backlog predictions are historical

Near the close, Nadav talks about COVID court closures and forecasts cases stretching from six months to three years, or three to ten. These are his period-specific warnings, not established current court waiting times; emergency court work did not simply cease in every case. Do not postpone urgent action or miss a deadline on the strength of a general forecast.

31:03 — Thanks to listeners and the production team

They thank listeners and one another, and again thank Sharon for the quiet technical setting that makes the conversation possible. The question to carry forward is which process and professional skills suit the actual conflict. A mediator need not be a lawyer in every setting, but cannot assume every legal, therapeutic or decision-making role, and the participants retain their choice.

Original episode page

Harvard: history of the Negotiation Project

Israeli Courts Administration: civil reform checklist

השאר תגובה

Skip to content