Collaborative divorce — Idit Shaham and Nadav Nishri | Episode 27

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

A detailed guide to Nadav Nishri’s conversation with lawyer and mediator Idit Shaham about collaborative divorce, professional teamwork and choosing a suitable process. The original recordings are in Hebrew. Chapter times follow the source transcript and are not synchronized translated captions.

Original Hebrew video

Watch on YouTube

Original Hebrew audio

Listen on Spotify

0:00 — A third route, and thanks to listeners

Nadav Nishri welcomes lawyer and mediator Idit Shaham to discuss collaborative divorce. They have known each other for roughly seven or eight years; he sought her out because of her leadership in this work in Israel. He also thanks listeners for the growing response to the podcast. The premise is that an unsuccessful mediation need not leave adversarial litigation as the only next option.

1:26 — The person beyond the professional title

The introduction mentions about forty years in law, gender studies at Lesley University in Massachusetts, amateur theatre and Rio Abierto dance. Idit describes pre-pandemic travel and her partner’s photographs decorating her unconventional professional website. These are recorded biographical details, not newly audited credentials. Although the edited introduction says she never appeared in court, her later story explicitly describes having done so before choosing another professional path.

2:33 — Why stay for this conversation?

Nadav jokes about being told to give an elevator pitch in the first ninety seconds. His pitch is representation within a cooperative setting: each person has someone protecting their interests, alongside emotional and other professional help. Calling this potentially life-saving expresses his strong belief, not a measured treatment effect or a promise that a particular family will obtain agreement.

3:49 — How Idit encountered the method

At the recording, she describes more than twenty years as a mediator. Recalling an earlier encounter with the method, she mentions a bar-association event with Canadian therapist Yuval Berger, who later taught an early training in Israel. What attracted her was a multidisciplinary team around the family, not just a different name for negotiation. Her account describes her own introduction to the approach, not proof that she alone invented it.

4:28 — Separation affects an extended family

Idit stresses that a family, not only a couple, lives through separation. The speakers refer to recent killings involving grandparents and escalating divorce disputes without supplying case documentation. Their concern is serious escalation, not evidence that litigation inevitably leads to violence, that a particular profession caused these incidents, or that fear excuses any violence.

5:18 — Fear for children is not a neurological exemption

Nadav invokes fight, freeze and flight and adds a supposed newly discovered defensive response concerning children. The recording supplies no research establishing that account. The practical concern is fear overwhelming judgment; it does not establish an uncontrollable mechanism that removes responsibility. Children’s protection and appropriate specialist help matter more than diagnosing a person from this shorthand.

5:59 — Why people fear involving lawyers

Idit hears couples reject lawyers because they fear escalation. They mention the film Marriage Story as a cultural illustration of a cooperative separation becoming adversarial, not documentary proof about all lawyers. Nadav recognizes similar requests in his practice. The collaborative proposal is to change the professional commitment and setting, rather than assume that having personal legal representation is itself the problem.

6:40 — Idit already makes room for necessary court action

She explicitly says some situations require representation, court proceedings and orders, while many others can support a respectful separation and continuing family ties. This qualification matters alongside their criticism of litigation. Preserving family connections is not a demand for friendship, unsafe contact or waiver of protection, legal rights, deadlines or independent advice.

7:14 — Collaborative law is broader than divorce

They use the Hebrew abbreviation gashtap and joke that it needs better branding. Idit also calls it collaborative law because the approach can apply to other disputes, although this episode focuses on divorce in Israel. It is a chosen dispute-resolution process, not a promise that all conflict types fit one method.

7:45 — A team with different responsibilities

Idit describes two lawyers trained in collaborative practice, one for each participant; one or two emotional-support professionals depending on complexity; a neutral child specialist bringing children’s voices; and a financial professional for company valuations, actuarial work or property appraisal. In the collaborative model, participants sign a participation agreement and lawyers do not continue representing them in subsequent contested litigation on that matter. Specific terms and legal requirements need checking.

Reference

8:26 — Her preference for a multidisciplinary team

Idit objects to calling a negotiation between two lawyers sufficient collaborative work, then expressly says not every professional is needed in every case. Her priority is responding to the needs that arise around the crisis. Team configurations differ in actual collaborative practice; her strong preference should not erase that variation or make every role compulsory regardless of need.

8:57 — Who keeps the larger picture visible?

Nadav argues that ordinary negotiations can lose the family-wide view when each lawyer focuses narrowly on one client. Emotional professionals can help maintain it, he says; his own law studies did not train him to handle intense feelings. He also notes that neutral actuarial or valuation expertise can be used in mediation. These are role distinctions and his experience, not proof all lawyers lack emotional skills.

10:10 — One support professional, or one for each person

Idit describes emotional support as important in a crisis, sometimes from one professional and sometimes separately for each participant when escalation is greater. People may not know how to ask for help or identify their need. Roles, qualifications and whether someone is a coach or a treating clinician should be clear; a team’s presence does not by itself guarantee safety or agreement.

10:40 — The year after separation and different kinds of support

Nadav describes the following year as personally formative and difficult, with possible discoveries of strength. He lists psychologists, coaches, psychotherapists, spiritual advisers and ThetaHealing practitioners as examples people turn to. These are not equivalent clinical qualifications or evidence bases. Personal growth is possible, not obligatory, and choosing support does not guarantee it or make continued distress someone’s fault.

11:37 — The problem of being heard

They think collaborative divorce has poor public visibility. Nadav contrasts quieter people who separate constructively with louder combative voices on social media; this is his observation, not a verified population statistic. Their request is that families hear about another option instead of seeing only mediation versus war.

12:25 — The cost objection and public services

Idit hears: if we can already talk, why pay for two lawyers and perhaps double, triple or quadruple the cost? She describes eight public centres at the time, operating through local authorities, social services or municipal associations with more accessible tariffs. This is a historical service description, not confirmation of present eligibility, prices, opening hours or universal affordability.

13:13 — Families should not be reduced to a source of money

She describes establishing centres for people with limited resources who need support but cannot afford it. Parents or grandparents sometimes mortgage property to fund adult children’s proceedings. Nadav describes including grandparents as supportive participants rather than merely a financial tap. Their inclusion requires appropriate agreement and boundaries; paying for a process does not confer control over the couple’s decisions.

14:15 — Mediation first: a preference, not a universal rule

Nadav says he will always favour trying mediation first; Idit initially agrees. This is their preference in the conversation, not a requirement to attempt mediation before protection or a professional assessment of suitability. The next examples complicate that preference and show why informed choice must remain with the people involved.

14:43 — Violence requires assessment, not an automatic upgrade

Idit says some cases involving violence may be better supported by a collaborative team with specialist knowledge; Nadav agrees with her suggestion. It must not become the blanket advice “violence means collaborative divorce.” Coercive control, danger, ability to decide freely, ongoing assessment and safety planning may make joint negotiation unsuitable. Needed protective or judicial intervention must remain available.

Reference

15:49 — A premarital or inherited apartment

They discuss a home owned before marriage or inherited later, rental income going into a joint account, renovations, investment and an informal statement among friends that the home belongs to both. These facts can generate genuine legal disagreement. Neither a premarital label nor shared rent or a casual promise determines every case automatically; advice must address the applicable law and evidence, without promising that either person will easily win.

17:07 — Nadav’s objection to narrowing everything into legal positions

Nadav says uncertain law or conflicting case outcomes can make creative mediation especially valuable. He would avoid letting competing legal claims dominate the discussion and asks how much of the children’s eventual inheritance is consumed by conflict. This is a process perspective, not a statement that law has no answers, that children already own the property, or that informed legal advice should be forgotten. Shared goals can frame individual needs and options.

18:10 — Idit defends the lawyers’ joint problem solving

She answers that collaborative lawyers do think together about legally workable, durable solutions that reassure both participants. Nadav calls this the spirit of mediation; she insists there is a difference beyond simply having a conversation. Their exchange preserves both creative human problem solving and the distinct contribution of legal representation rather than declaring the professions interchangeable.

18:51 — A human approach does not create a clinical qualification

Nadav praises Idit’s holistic view of adults and children and says the human work is harder than drafting the result. She recalls being called a therapeutic lawyer and a lawyer-like therapist, but explicitly says she is not actually a therapist. Their warmth does not authorize either person to practice outside their qualifications or make the legal detail unimportant.

20:14 — Drafting, mediation and legal limits

They debate who may write an agreement; Nadav argues against treating all writing as lawyers’ exclusive work and refers to section 20. This should not be turned into universal permission for anyone to supply paid legal services. Writing one’s own terms, recording a mediation settlement, legal advice and professional drafting raise distinct questions under local rules. Appropriate expertise and necessary approval remain important.

Reference

20:51 — Power differences are not only financial

Idit mentions control over family money, unequal experience negotiating because one person does it daily, and unequal emotional readiness to separate. One may already have finished grieving while the other has just begun. She believes a collaborative support structure can help more effectively than a mediator struggling alone; it does not automatically eliminate power or make consent voluntary.

22:05 — Failure can happen in either direction

They suggest looking for collaborative practitioners after unsuccessful mediation rather than assuming court is next. Idit then describes receiving a couple for mediation after a failed collaborative process whose lawyers, in her account, retained a litigation mindset. The example matters: the label is no guarantee, and changing routes can also mean returning to mediation.

22:43 — From romantic partners to parenting partners

Nadav values mediation’s opportunity to develop a different way of communicating and become partners in parenting after the romantic partnership ends. Going straight to another format may, in his view, miss that opportunity. It is a possible benefit, not a condition that everyone grow, reconcile romantically or become friends before an agreement is legitimate.

23:10 — The “we always say yes” remark needs a boundary

Nadav describes reluctance to refuse cases because he worries people will receive less experienced help or move toward conflict. He also admits how difficult accepted cases can become and later describes referral elsewhere. The remark is not a current promise to accept every family or a sound rule to ignore competence, violence screening, suitability or the participants’ freedom to leave.

23:36 — People reach the separation at different times

They discuss one person exhausted with waiting while the other is only starting to grieve, sometimes with a new partner already present. They see that the change in life and fear can itself be painful, regardless of its cause. The exchange does not endorse infidelity, assign equal blame or require the hurt person to minimize betrayal.

24:10 — A hundred messages in two hours

Nadav describes leaving a two-hour mediation meeting to find around a hundred difficult messages in a couple’s WhatsApp group. He cannot answer everything. The example shows the workload and limits of one professional, and why a clearer support structure or a different process may sometimes be needed; it is not an invitation to expect constant personal availability.

24:33 — Information, advice and a firm boundary

He describes someone denying the other any entitlement in a shared asset and wishing a personal lawyer could state boundaries firmly. A mediator can lose trust if perceived as one side’s adviser. They distinguish neutral information from personal legal advice; neither the anecdote nor a general reference to property and guardianship law decides a listener’s entitlement or justifies withholding independent advice.

25:24 — Criticism is not a verdict on a whole profession

Nadav criticizes advice he has encountered as inaccurate or escalating and expresses frustration with professional accountability. These are his reported experiences and opinions, not verified findings about every consultation, most lawyers or a named regulator’s conduct. Their practical concern is choosing competent, suitably trained help that can represent interests without deliberately inflaming fear.

25:55 — The child in distress and fifty to a hundred thousand shekels

Nadav—not Idit—recounts a family already supported by welfare and professionals because a child was self-harming. As drafts progressed, a parent consulted a lawyer whom he describes as urging a fight over fifty thousand shekels, or a fifty-to-one-hundred-thousand difference. This is his account, without an independently established legal entitlement or outcome. A child’s self-harm needs qualified urgent assessment and care; mediation is not its treatment.

27:01 — They did not find an available local team

He says the family searched but could not find an affordable collaborative route in their area. In his account, discussing the limits of the current process and alternatives eventually helped both people reach a solution. The outcome is not proof that threatening withdrawal works, nor a reason to pressure someone into agreement or to claim a collaborative service was actually provided.

27:34 — The locations mentioned in the recording

Idit names Bnei Shimon, Ashdod, Be’er Sheva, Ramat Gan, Rosh HaAyin, Holon through Bein LeBein, Rehovot with an outside operator, and the Adler Institute in Kfar Saba. She also mentions the Rackman Center at Bar-Ilan as offering a related form, and says northern provision was lacking despite her efforts. These are recording-era examples and her appeal for more centres, not an updated directory or an assurance every service is identical.

29:28 — Why she stopped representing in court

Idit recalls working as legal adviser at a shelter for abused women and appearing in a district court long ago. She found a client’s questioning humiliating and abusive, asked the judge to stop it and was told to sit. She decided not to return to that form of practice. Her story directly contradicts the edited article’s “never appeared in court” wording; it is her experience, not a finding about every judge.

30:48 — The disagreement at the end must remain visible

Idit adds that sometimes there is no alternative to court and many lawyers do their work faithfully. Nadav objects and again favours therapeutic mediation even for emotional or mental-health difficulty; they leave the disagreement for another time. Neither difficulty nor a label proves negotiation is safe or adequate. Necessary court protection, rights and qualified mental-health care must not be ruled out.

31:18 — Share the option, not a guaranteed outcome

They thank one another and ask listeners to read about collaborative divorce and share with those considering separation. Nadav describes limited independent resources, points to their sites and social media, and thanks Sharon Kaniel for the recording. The invitation is to learn and choose appropriately; their conviction that the message is right is not evidence that every claim, service or outcome has been independently verified.

Original episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content