Personal mediation guidance and legal advice — Nadav Nishri and Bat-El Bar Giora | Episode 33

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

A detailed guide to Nadav Nishri’s conversation with Bat-El Bar Giora about preparing for a separation or another conflict. Both original recordings are in Hebrew; chapter times refer to the source transcript, not synchronized translated captions.

Original Hebrew video

Watch on YouTube

Original Hebrew audio

Listen on Spotify

00:00 — Mediation concerns many kinds of relationships

Nadav Nishri introduces conflict in couples, families, businesses, companies, organizations and dealings with suppliers. Wherever people have relationships, differences can arise and choices must be made about handling them. Divorce is their main example and area of experience in this conversation, not the only setting in which mediation can support people in reaching their own agreements.

00:40 — Representation and supported decision-making are different roles

He questions the habit of treating lawyers as the automatic managers of every conflict and expecting a court to decide. Mediation offers a different role: participants work toward resolution themselves with a mediator’s help. That distinction does not make representation, legal information or judicial protection illegitimate. The relevant question is which support and protections a particular situation requires.

01:05 — Bat-El Bar Giora brings experience from both sides of the room

The guest is Bat-El Bar Giora, a mediator working with Nadav. He says he accompanied her own divorce mediation; she later studied with him and undertook practical training. They have known one another for years. Her personal experience informs this discussion, without making her story a template for every separation or an independently measured endorsement of outcomes.

01:41 — The step before choosing what to do

They ask what happens when someone receives difficult news and must decide whose advice to seek. Nadav recalls a previous conversation with Shiri Orlev about the period of carrying a thought privately before telling anyone. The uncertainty can arise in relationships and other conflicts. The aim is to examine a direction before reacting automatically, while not postponing urgent protection or necessary legal advice.

02:33 — Two kinds of consultation ask different questions

Nadav describes mediation-oriented personal consultation as planning a process toward a desired future. It explores goals and a broad set of family, financial and sometimes legal tools. One-person preliminary listening is legitimate; when people enter joint mediation, first establish shared goals, then explore individual needs within that foundation. Consulting one person is not itself a joint agreement or a mandate to decide for the absent participant.

03:21 — What legal advice contributes

He describes legal advice as examining the legal position, advantages and disadvantages, litigation risks and possible outcomes. It is a legal opinion about the situation, whereas mediation-oriented work also asks what life people want to build. These functions can complement one another. Good legal advice can consider broader objectives too; neither professional role needs to be reduced to a caricature of the other.

03:38 — The income and maintenance example is not a calculation

Nadav contrasts supposedly clear questions with uncertain family outcomes, using a rhetorical criminal example and then incomes of six thousand and seven thousand shekels. He imagines maintenance answers ranging from zero to six thousand. Neither that range nor the income figures establish anyone’s obligation. His statement that there is “no law” needs qualification: Israeli maintenance has statutory and personal-law frameworks, interpreted through relevant case law and individual facts. A confession also does not remove criminal procedural safeguards.

Reference

04:14 — Needs, security and stability widen the conversation

The questions become: what is needed, what provides security and stability, and what helps the other person see the participant’s situation? That is broader than asking only what can be claimed. It does not erase enforceable rights, turn needs into a universal legal formula or require giving up an entitlement. Personal and practical questions can inform choices alongside accurate legal advice.

04:42 — A criticism of the system rather than all lawyers

Nadav explicitly says he is not against lawyers. He is concerned about approaches that fail to see children, affected people or a business threatened by escalating proceedings. He wants a view of the whole system and future relationships. His recollection that four years of law study taught persuasion and sharpening disputes rather than building relationships describes his experience, not every lawyer’s education or intentions.

05:33 — Conflicting advice can arrive in the mediation room

He describes people being told first to ask a lawyer what they can receive, then bringing an asserted minimum of eighteen hundred shekels in maintenance into mediation while the other person has opposite advice. The number is an example of a claim made to him, not a universal minimum or an updated tariff. Asking how an opinion was reached can be useful without assuming that all conflicting opinions are worthless or that the law has no standards.

06:44 — An individual consultation is not a strategy for harming someone

They describe a private meeting to explain options, somewhat like mediation but without two participants. Both reject helping a client damage or “get” the other person. Their declared aim is to encourage cooperation and pursue a viable future. This is their ethical approach to the service; it is not proof that every person consulting them has harmless intentions or that an absent partner must trust or choose them.

07:18 — They expressly acknowledge uncertainty about confidentiality

Nadav initially calls the consultation confidential, then asks whether a mediator meeting one person outside a mediation has legal privilege. He thinks so but explicitly acknowledges a question mark. Preserve that uncertainty: privacy commitments, formal mediation protections and evidentiary privilege are not interchangeable. Before a standalone meeting, clarify its status, recordkeeping and disclosure arrangements rather than assuming that the mediator’s title automatically protects every conversation.

Reference

07:45 — Cooperation is the purpose, not permission to reveal private advice

Nadav says they would stand behind advice aimed at cooperation rather than harm, even if litigation followed. That expresses confidence in the approach, not blanket consent to disclose someone’s consultation. Later joint work requires transparency about prior involvement, appropriate impartiality and informed choices by both participants. The other person may prefer a different mediator. Support for cooperation does not require self-sacrifice, friendship or accepting unsafe contact.

08:27 — Where would you like to be after the whirlpool?

They ask what a person wants life to look like years after this difficult period. Nadav allows telling what happened, while directing attention toward the future. His whirlpool image asks not only whether someone gets through, but where they will be afterward. This does not forbid discussing the past, grief or anger, nor does it require the two people to choose a shared romantic future.

09:01 — Imagining freely, then using a destination to examine action

Nadav suggests imagining the most desired life, temporarily setting aside money and health constraints as an exercise. Writing or visualizing it creates a reference point: does a proposed action move toward that future? The exercise opens possibilities; it does not make real financial, health or legal constraints vanish. Within joint mediation, a shared foundation provides the frame for considering each person’s hopes.

09:33 — Write, record or put the direction on a board

He offers the idea openly for people to try themselves: write the destination, record it, say it aloud or display it prominently so as not to lose direction. It is a tool, not a compulsory ritual or evidence that someone without a clear vision is failing. Goals can be revised as information changes, and informed refusal or seeking protection can itself serve an important goal.

09:51 — Bat-El notices the vulnerability of the uncertain stage

She describes the period when thoughts become mixed and stability is shaken as a time when a person can lose their way. Holding a goal can help her clients orient themselves. These are her observations, not a clinical diagnosis or proof that one technique resolves anxiety. Uncertainty and strong emotion are allowed; clarity need not arrive before a person is entitled to support.

10:14 — Seeking help can include therapy

If defining goals is hard, Nadav suggests speaking with a therapist and emphasizes that people are social beings who can need help. Both express confidence that assistance can make a difference. This is an invitation, not compulsory treatment, a promise of recovery or a test of readiness for mediation. People can choose appropriate support while retaining autonomy and access to urgent services and advice.

10:44 — Lay out practical tools: money, work, housing and education

Once there is a direction, they explore resources and needs, household costs, where someone works and when work ends. Housing, children’s education and where the children live are part of the picture. The task is to examine connected realities rather than negotiate an isolated number. Reliable financial and legal input may be needed alongside the mediator’s skill in organizing the process.

11:10 — Wanting all the time with children is not yet a workable plan

Nadav asks what is realistic and what is actually needed, rather than automatically seeking as much parenting time as possible. He uses one hundred percent as an extreme example and asks whether children want that and whether it suits them. Work and the possibility of a new relationship also matter. These questions do not prescribe a universal schedule, erase either parent’s responsibilities or make a new romance more important than a child’s needs.

11:39 — Helping children through a crisis without guaranteeing growth

Instead of asking only whether separation will harm children, he asks how to reduce harm, provide an example of resolving differences by talking and allow possibilities for growth. This is a parenting aim, not proof that all children will be unaffected or must grow from pain. Children should not carry adult decisions or act as coordinators. The speakers use personal pronouns while intending the examples to apply across genders.

12:05 — One or two meetings as their described service

They describe consultation as usually one or two meetings that provide tools and direction. That is their practice as presented at the recording, not a guaranteed sufficient dose for every conflict. The number does not replace assessment of complexity, safety or the need for specialist help. Guidance can be practical without promising an identical transformation for everyone.

12:19 — Whose experience is shaping the advice?

They ask how to distinguish advice that advances broad interests from another person’s account of a painful separation framed only as war. Personal stories can be valuable but may not match the listener’s circumstances. The point is to evaluate assumptions and fit, not diagnose an adviser as traumatized, exclude independent advice or reject credible warnings of harm.

12:38 — Family and trusted people can be resources

They consider supportive family, grandparents and perhaps a person the other parent particularly trusts. These may widen the options before legal tactics dominate. Involving someone requires attention to willingness, privacy, conflicts of interest and safety; relatives are not automatically neutral or entitled to receive confidential information. Shared goals can guide how support is used without giving a third party decision-making power.

12:54 — How to tell the other person, and whether couple therapy fits

They discuss announcing a separation and strongly recommend considering couple therapy, including as a place to talk about parting. That option depends on willingness and suitability; it need not mean trying to preserve the marriage. It can sit among other tools rather than replacing legal advice or urgent protection. The proposed process belongs to the participants, not to a professional’s preferred relationship outcome.

13:13 — Their account of access, including online meetings

Nadav describes individual meetings with a male or female mediator, work across Israel and Zoom meetings with people abroad. These are service descriptions from the recording, not confirmation of current availability or authorization to provide every professional service in every country. A person should check the actual service, relevant jurisdiction and what kind of consultation is being offered.

13:25 — The price discussion is historical, not a current quote

They speak openly about cost, mentioning roughly six hundred and fifty to eight hundred shekels and around nine hundred, varying by timing and mediator. Nadav himself notes prices may change, and they joke about index-linking. They praise the value strongly. These remarks are not a current fee list, an independently verified cheapest or best service, or a guarantee of savings relative to every alternative.

14:18 — Legal advice remains a distinct and legitimate option

They return to how to receive legal advice, distinguishing a known legal rule from a professional estimate of what a court may do. They acknowledge different assessments and uncertainty. Nadav’s strong dislike of litigation does not make court access wrong or unnecessary. Current, independent advice may help someone understand rights, risks, enforceability and deadlines while choosing a cooperative process.

14:48 — First question: where does this legal proposition come from?

Nadav proposes asking to see the law behind a claimed entitlement. A useful answer may involve legislation, applicable personal law, binding judgments and the facts—not just a sentence in a statute. Case law is not merely optional opinion, and a risk assessment is not worthless because it is uncertain. Ask what is settled, what is contested and which assumptions drive the recommendation.

14:58 — Parents and property cannot be reduced to two slogans

He names matrimonial-property and guardianship law and summarizes parenthood and property as “half and half” unless there is another agreement. That shorthand needs qualification. Parenthood does not automatically prescribe equal time, and Israeli resource balancing concerns relevant asset values with statutory exclusions and possible exceptions, not literally splitting every asset. An agreement may require formal approval; the applicable law and individual circumstances matter.

Reference

15:13 — Second question: how does the proposed step serve the future?

If an adviser proposes an application, a filing or another legal tactic, ask how it helps reach the broader destination, including life with the children. The question connects strategy with consequences rather than treating winning an isolated issue as the only goal. It does not require avoiding a filing that is needed for protection or preserving rights. A useful plan can include both dialogue and timely formal action.

15:25 — Third question: is the outcome actually guaranteed?

Nadav suggests asking whether the adviser will commit to the predicted result and says people will discover that no one guarantees it. The practical distinction is between a promise and a reasoned assessment of chances. A professional’s refusal to guarantee a judicial outcome does not itself show bad advice, and mediation outcomes cannot be guaranteed either. Ask about uncertainty, alternatives and costs.

15:40 — Acting for broad interests without stepping on someone else

Nadav welcomes hearing different advice and describes ongoing personal support during a mediation. His goal is to keep actions aligned with broad interests without helping harm the other person, while recognizing that cooperation involves mutual consideration. Mutuality is not an obligation to waive rights, accept coercion or make the other person cooperate. The mediator supports a process; participants retain their own decisions.

16:11 — An invitation to consider one hour of orientation

He recommends that people considering divorce seek this kind of consultation as well as legal advice, suggesting an hour can change perspective. This is his recommendation about a service he offers, not evidence that everyone must purchase it. Its possible value is a wider view of choices; suitability, cost and the freedom to use another practitioner remain relevant.

16:22 — Bat-El’s observations: fear, practical questions and some relief

She describes people arriving frightened and seeming more empowered or calmer after a conversation. She emphasizes practical questions: what can be done, what is needed and how to speak with the other person. These are observations, not a measured clinical effect or a requirement to leave calm. Anger, uncertainty and grief do not invalidate participation or mean the person has failed the meeting.

17:11 — Choosing where and when to express difficult words

Bat-El says she sometimes encourages a client to say something to her rather than immediately to the other person, perhaps not then or at all. This concerns timing and a suitable place for expression, not banning anger, silencing a victim or withholding information someone is entitled to receive. The aim is communication that serves a chosen future while preserving safety, truth and independent judgment.

17:28 — You cannot force another person to adopt your narrative

Nadav says imposing one person’s account of the relationship on the other can ignite conflict. They suggest developing a new account of one’s next life and finding agency within oneself. That does not mean the hurt person caused the problem, must forgive, cannot report wrongdoing or must solve everything alone. Change need not depend on the other person endorsing the same history.

18:03 — Before an aggressive step, get a broader picture

They invite a call before hostile paperwork or action, hoping that a wider view can prevent avoidable escalation. That invitation does not postpone legal deadlines, evidence preservation or urgent protection. Dialogue is one possible tool, not a compulsory agreement. They thank one another and describe this short episode as an important message.

18:18 — Resources and voluntary sharing

Nadav mentions the podcast, website, books and videos as places to find more information and asks listeners to share. These are additional resources, not replacements for advice tailored to an individual situation. The invitation to spread a message is voluntary; the recording does not establish a current publication schedule or guarantee that every resource answers every question.

18:35 — Other practitioners can offer this approach too

He closes by acknowledging separation companions, other mediators and former students who offer cooperative personal guidance. He would welcome clients but does not claim to be the only good option. They end with “mediation saves lives” as their slogan, not an established clinical effectiveness claim. The practical invitation is to seek suitable help before unnecessary escalation while keeping choice, rights and safety intact.

Original episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content