Episode 78: Mutual responsibility, peace and dialogue between Haredi and secular Jews

0:01 — A conversation across communities

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri speaks with Rabbi Hanoch Weitman, a Haredi mediator on his team, about mutual responsibility, peace in Jewish tradition and relations between Haredi and secular Israelis. The recording is in Hebrew. Against the background of war, they ask how people with different beliefs, authorities and ways of life can build a shared future without erasing their identities. Their optimism is a position developed in conversation, not a promise that every conflict can be resolved.

Original recording in Hebrew — Spotify

Listen on Spotify

Original video in Hebrew — YouTube

1:47 — From an online course to working together

Nadav recalls meeting Hanoch in an online basic mediation course, followed by a practicum and professional experience together. He praises Hanoch’s discretion, humility and influence, recalling that he shared Torah teachings with the group. Their connection also grew through parallels between Jewish sources and the New Partnership approach: mediation as a way of relating to people, extending beyond divorce into family, community and public life.

2:55 — Aaron, Moses and two people in conflict

Hanoch contrasts Moses as an image of adjudication with Aaron as a pursuer of peace. In the traditional story he retells, Reuven and Shimon quarrel. Aaron visits each separately, sits respectfully and describes the other person’s regret. Each can then acknowledge his own remorse, and their next meeting becomes an embrace. This is a religious teaching about softening hostility, not verified documentation of the first professional mediator. His references to roughly 3,300 years ago belong to that traditional framing. A modern mediator should not invent remorse or disclose private conversations without permission.

4:49 — Compromise and an attribution that needs separating

Hanoch links peace with the rabbinic discussion of compromise, referring to an ancient tradition approximately 1,800 years old. The recording conflates two books when it associates Maimonides with the Shulchan Arukh. The relevant passages are Maimonides’ Mishneh Torah, Sanhedrin 22:4, and Joseph Karo’s Shulchan Arukh, Choshen Mishpat 12:2. They discuss offering litigants a choice between judgment and compromise, with qualifications concerning the stage of proceedings. These religious sources are not a statement of the civil law applicable to every listener.

5:24 — Community as a resource, without idealising it

Nadav values the community support he encounters in Haredi life: people need not face difficulty alone, and neighbours will still share a future after a dispute. Informal peacemaking by rabbis and other trusted people can help sustain that fabric. He contrasts this with isolation and divisive public leadership. The proposal is to learn from mutual assistance without claiming that every community behaves alike or that someone must accept a community authority’s preferred solution.

7:30 — Peace, wholeness and the story of Truth

Hanoch connects shalom with wholeness and invokes a midrash about the creation of humanity: Truth objects because humans will lie, and Truth is cast to the earth. The relevant text is Genesis Rabbah 8:5. He reads it as an invitation to flexibility in the pursuit of peace. This is a religious interpretation, not permission to abandon facts, mislead participants or disregard rights. The conversation’s spiritual language about inner peace is not a clinical guarantee.

8:14 — Peace asks something of us

Nadav hears a demanding idea: peace requires a willingness to change, rather than requiring only the other side to accept a fixed position. He describes its importance through an emphatic comparison with the Ten Commandments, not by claiming an additional commandment. When people answer wishes for peace with despair, he wants to reopen possibility. For him, peace should not be dismissed as the property of one political camp; it is a shared value that can coexist with real differences.

10:07 — Learning tools rather than controlling another person

After a light exchange about names, Nadav describes the free online mediation course available at the time of recording and his wish to make tools accessible across communities and languages. Availability today must be checked separately. The practical direction is to identify interests and the future people want to share. His belief that encounters bring challenges one can face is personal encouragement, not an instruction to endure abuse or avoid outside protection. Neither speaker claims that all Haredi people already know or practise these skills.

12:20 — The three heads of the letter shin

Hanoch uses the three upper strokes of the Hebrew letter shin as an image: two outer positions and a middle point helping them meet. It is a metaphor from a book he recalls, not a clinical explanation or proof about the letter’s origin. Talking only with one’s own circle, whether in a mikveh or a bar, does not create contact across groups. During disputes about judicial reform, naming each side’s fears together could offer a different starting point from arguing within separate camps.

13:21 — Ofir and the personal meaning of wartime solidarity

Nadav tells of his cousin Ofir, whom he describes as being like a brother, serving in Gaza at the time. A message that Ofir was coming home led to an emotional weekend; after returning on Sunday, there was another stretch of roughly two weeks without news. These are circumstances recalled in the recording, not a present-day status update. Nadav sees people of different backgrounds sharing harsh conditions at the front as an image of connection. It is a personal observation, not a representative survey. Nadav places the story in an earlier episode with Yotam; it was Ofir who had encouraged him to keep spreading that language.

15:28 — Eight likes and a real disagreement about media

Nadav contrasts a peace-oriented post receiving eight likes with the attention anger can attract. Hanoch invokes the familiar news-value image of a man biting a dog. They do not entirely agree about responsibility: Hanoch thinks some workers may not see the damage, while Nadav believes some knowingly participate. Nadav supports this with a private dinner anecdote about unnamed campaign workers and livelihood. That account is unverified; it does not establish that all journalists, politicians or campaigners knowingly manipulate people. Money and moral worth are separate issues in his criticism.

18:02 — A civilian network of people who can talk

Nadav’s estimate that at least 95% want ordinary security, health, work and a future for their children is his impression, not polling evidence. His practical proposal is a broad civilian network, metaphorically an “army of mediators”, in towns, workplaces, businesses, families and communities. People could begin with conversation and seek a trained mediator when needed. This would develop human infrastructure alongside formal institutions; it does not remove access to courts or necessary protective services.

19:45 — Two planets, or people who have not met?

Hanoch describes respectful visits to the team in Tel Aviv, without pressure to change religion, and contrasts them with the impression of two hostile planets conveyed publicly. He worries that repeated attention to an isolated spitting incident can amplify it. That concern does not excuse harm or mean that incidents should not be documented. Their criticism of polarising political incentives remains a viewpoint, not proof that every troubling report is false. Nadav returns to the lack of sustained encounters between ordinary people.

21:20 — Letters after a seminar in Safed

At sixteen, Nadav attended the first two days of a Gesher seminar in Safed before leaving for work. There he met Emily Amrousi, with whom he subsequently exchanged letters for months about left and right and withdrawal from the Golan Heights. They disagreed while retaining interest and respect. He later recognised her in a public role and sent her the old letters. The important point in his recollection is the relationship, not agreement. He wants similar encounters for adults as well as children, without a hidden mission to convert participants or impose a way of life.

23:29 — Encounters can challenge inherited stereotypes

Hanoch mentions Kesher Yehudi meetings, including encounters with pre-army participants and Shabbat hospitality. He recalls one participant’s anger that school and parents had not introduced him to this richness before; it is one person’s response, not a finding about all schools. Nadav acknowledges growing up with hostility towards Haredi people and later reconsidering that inherited stereotype. He speaks about his own development, not the upbringing of every secular Israeli.

24:34 — When one parent changes religious practice

They describe a couple in which the mother left religious observance. The father feared losing his children, while the mother feared losing her privacy. Once those different fears were heard, some practical gaps proved manageable in that particular case. Hanoch places children’s wellbeing ahead of a contest over observance. The principle is not to diagnose a parent through religious identity or to equate secular life with illness. Serious distress needs appropriate professional attention; dialogue is not a substitute for protection when someone is unsafe.

26:14 — Plan for staying together and for separating

Nadav describes work towards reconciliation alongside a possible divorce agreement. Exploring both routes can reduce uncertainty and clarify what remaining together would require, without forcing either reconciliation or separation. He asks what future the parents want: how the children will grow, what values they will receive and what life each adult hopes to lead. Shared goals form the foundation; individual needs are then worked out within it. This is more useful than beginning and ending with who did what to whom.

27:14 — Kashrut, Shabbat and one whole child

Concrete questions include kosher food, travel on Shabbat and how children can keep continuity with earlier values while encountering a changed world. Different households need not become identical. Nadav’s comparison with Solomon’s judgment is about seeing the whole child, not dividing the child into competing parental projects. It does not require surrendering safety or lawful rights. The aim is space for each person’s needs within a shared commitment to the child, while allowing the parents to retain their own identities.

28:27 — Parents offer values; children develop choices

Hanoch tells an observant parent that they can offer tools and beliefs but cannot control the child’s eventual religious choice. Nadav recalls a particularly harsh legal battle followed by the children becoming secular. That recollection is not proof that litigation causes a particular identity, nor is secular identity itself a failure. Their shared boundary goes both ways: a child cannot simply be forced into either religious or secular conviction.

29:28 — Criticism, accountability and people worth hearing

Nadav challenges Hanoch as a representative of his community: he wants its wisdom about peace to be more visible than extreme political voices. Hanoch answers that sensational incidents attract coverage while thoughtful people remain unheard. Discussing someone throwing something at a woman over modesty, he rejects humiliation as religiously unjustified. His condemnation should not be diluted into an excuse for harmful behaviour, nor expanded into a judgement about an entire community. The disagreement makes their respectful relationship more substantive.

30:23 — Building change from below

Nadav asks listeners for ideas, participation and help sharing the episode and the mediation tools discussed. The course invitation belongs to the time of recording. Hanoch suggests that change can develop from grassroots conversations. Both acknowledge that communicating a complex message takes time and has no magic solution; more people carrying it could help it spread. This is an invitation to sustained human contact, not a promise of inevitable success.

32:21 — A political interpretation and a closing commitment

Nadav ends with a strong interpretation linking the polarisation he criticises to the circumstances of October 7. It is his political reading, not an established causal explanation of the attacks; it neither assigns collective guilt nor justifies atrocities. His closing commitment is to encounter people beyond clothes and labels and help spread a language of peace. They thank listeners, invite sharing and responses, and wish for quiet and peace. The transcript ends at 33:31, close to the catalogued 33:33 recording.

Original episode and Hebrew text

Sources for the religious references

השאר תגובה

Skip to content