Parenting-time disputes after divorce, with Alona Shaked — Episode 130

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

A detailed translated guide to Nadav Nishri and mediator Alona Shaked discussing real listener questions about parenting time. Alona collected the questions and is introduced as leading the team’s post-divorce work at the time of recording. Original audio is Hebrew.

00:00 — “Mediation sounds good, but what about my problem?”

Alona brings questions from people who may accept the idea of agreement yet cannot see how to reach it with their former partner. Some have a mediated agreement; others have a court decision. The examples concern work, collection times, holidays and gaps in an existing schedule.

The discussion is about how people can approach a problem, not a legal determination of any listener’s obligations.

03:40 — A verdict about who is right does not arrange collection

Many questions finish with “who is right?” The speakers ask what happens after someone receives that answer: it still does not collect a child or create a workable calendar. They redirect attention to what the family needs and what could function.

That practical shift does not make rights, responsibility or safety irrelevant. It separates evaluating an actual legal question from expecting a winning argument to repair communication.

05:59 — Clear terms and flexibility can belong together

Alona asks whether people need to fight about every half-hour. Nadav distinguishes clear agreed terms from flexibility in daily life, and they find common ground there. Unclear arrangements create a different problem from a specific request to vary a clear one.

Flexibility is built through conduct over time, not demanded as a debt. An agreed departure from a schedule should be understood by both; no one should assume that a wish for cooperation cancels the existing arrangement.

07:12 — A new job conflicts with two children’s collection times

A listener has changed jobs and cannot leave early several times a week. One collection day also clashes with a fixed meeting day. He asks to change days or remove one, and the other parent refuses.

Nadav points out that the other household is independent, with its own work, needs and plans. A real difficulty in his job does not automatically become her responsibility. The first task is to understand both sets of constraints, not guess why she is refusing or label her motives.

10:01 — Build a conversation, not a disguised demand

They suggest making room to hear how the other parent is doing before asking for a change. Alona stresses that this cannot be a pleasant opening followed immediately by “so take Monday”. Rebuilding a channel is a process.

A mediator, parenting professional or other appropriate support can help where direct conversation is difficult and safe to pursue. If a new arrangement brings more income, the family can discuss how benefits and burdens might be shared rather than one parent gaining while the other absorbs the work.

12:30 — The solution need not fall entirely on the other parent

Alona broadens the options: a willing relative, a suitable babysitter, an activity or another practical arrangement may help with collection. The other parent may know useful possibilities without being obliged to do every extra task.

These require consent, practical checks and care appropriate to the children. The children themselves are not the negotiators. The purpose is a wider set of options within a shared aim of reliable care, not a new way to shift all responsibility elsewhere.

16:12 — Fire-service shifts change more than one calendar

A listener accepted a fire-and-rescue role after a long selection process, then realised the rotating shifts did not fit the fixed parenting pattern. His former partner would consider a permanent swap, not an unpredictable schedule.

The speakers recognise the value of the work and the other parent’s need for stability. Alona challenges treating the shift requirement as an unforeseeable surprise: major job decisions need a care plan. Nadav highlights the effects on everyone’s work, relationships and time with children.

20:14 — Discuss the financial picture and real alternatives

They discuss that a shift pattern may already have existed in the marriage or may be a proposed change; separation can still alter what is workable. Children’s ages, actual care needs and paid support may affect the options.

Sharing some financial benefit or funding extra care can be a negotiation topic, not a price that guarantees agreement. The programme’s playful figures are illustrations, not a fee schedule. Another role or a later career change may also be worth considering; neither parent’s autonomy disappears.

25:04 — Holiday mornings: sleep, work and a whole usable day

One parent wants morning handovers during school breaks so a day can be used for work or parenting. The other, working from home, favours a later start for the children. Nadav recommends explaining one’s own constraints instead of judging the other household.

They discuss age, activities and the children’s actual needs, including a possible middle time rather than only early morning or noon. The example is not a universal ten-o’clock rule. Different educational preferences should not turn one timing problem into a fight about every aspect of parenting.

29:02 — If a small scheduling issue keeps reopening old pain

A schedule can evolve as children grow. If even a modest adjustment becomes impossible, the speakers suggest addressing the recurring relationship pattern as well as the isolated problem. Individual support may help someone change how they respond.

One person can decline retaliation and protect children from an argument, but cannot guarantee the other will cooperate or stop harmful behaviour. Persistent conflict does not by itself diagnose a personality disorder or PTSD, and it does not make the person needing protection responsible for creating peace.

34:17 — Hosting dinner and travelling south need not have one answer

A holiday question pits afternoon preparation for hosting against an early journey to avoid traffic. Alona clarifies that hosting most holidays does not mean having the children for most holidays. The constraints differ.

A workable response may use different handover times depending on who is travelling or hosting. Fairness need not mean identical arrangements. Their informal family examples illustrate possibilities, not a requirement for every former couple to celebrate together.

40:47 — The court decision covers festivals but not school breaks

A listener dreads repeated disputes because the document does not address all school holidays. Nadav emphasises a longer-term parental relationship; Alona brings the focus back to planning the actual calendar away from the immediate pressure of an approaching break.

Look at a later holiday or the year ahead, list the relevant days and seek a clear arrangement. Do not infer a universal legal default from their discussion: the document, local rules and any needed formal change require suitable advice. Early planning cannot guarantee agreement, but avoids adding last-minute plans to the dispute.

50:37 — Talk about the issue without attacking the person

Nadav asks people to distinguish an opinion from the person holding it and avoid familiar insults about relatives or other triggers. Alona identifies a need underneath the calendar question: knowing in advance what life will look like. A particular date may matter less than predictability.

Supported discussion can hold future goals, facts, needs and genuine emotion together. No magic phrase, dinner invitation or therapeutic timetable guarantees success. The final invitation is to seek appropriate help, build a usable decision-making framework and keep children outside the struggle over how it is built.

Listen to episode 130

Original Hebrew audio and video. The text is an edited episode guide, not a verbatim transcript or an English recording.

Listen on Spotify

Read the original Hebrew episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content