
Nadav Nishri speaks with mediators Dana Gila and Mariela Yavetz Buchnik about consensus building at the University of Haifa Faculty of Law after the outbreak of war in October 2023. The conversation situates itself in January 2024. This detailed edited guide follows the full Hebrew transcript; chapter times point to the original recording. It presents the guests’ account of one process, rather than an independent evaluation of its results.
Listen to the original episode in Hebrew
03:16 — A faculty facing an escalating crisis
Dana describes hostile exchanges on social media, fear among Jewish and Arab students, and tensions involving staff. The immediate question was how everyone could return to studying and working together. The faculty formed a shared-life team. Rather than impose a conduct document from above, it sought a participatory process involving students and academic, administrative and clinical staff.
06:25 — A question people can influence
Mariela explains why they did not begin by debating the political conflict. They formulated a practical question: how can everyone help create a safe place for work and learning during a crisis and afterwards? It addressed something urgent and shared, with an outcome participants could influence. This did not require denying different identities, fears or opinions, or pretending the wider conflict had been resolved.
10:18 — Personal conversations before the large meeting
The mediators held dozens of individual conversations, often on Zoom because of wartime conditions. They listened to what mattered, what frightened people and what might help. They invited a broad range of stakeholders and actively approached influential voices. Strong or dissenting views were treated as information about needs, rather than people to label “problematic”. These conversations built trust before anyone entered a large room.
13:24 — An invitation built with the community
Participants helped formulate the invitation sent in the leadership’s name to the wider faculty. They did not all sign it; they had a chance to consider and influence its wording. The guests call this expanding the partnership. An invitation already discussed with those most involved was less likely to arrive as a surprise or another instruction from management.
19:19 — A structured space for the first encounter
About thirty people attended the first, three-hour meeting. The facilitators acknowledged the commitment involved in coming. Each person had a short, protected speaking turn without interruption; the mediators asked questions and reflected needs and feelings. The structure supported a difficult first face-to-face encounter after a long period apart. Dana recalls informal conversations afterwards that had previously seemed unlikely.
23:14 — Reflecting what was heard and acknowledging hurt
In a second round, participants could describe something new or moving they had heard. The mediators also invited recognition of another person’s hurt. Understanding that someone was injured by words does not necessarily mean agreeing with that person, retracting an opinion or offering an apology. The guests describe such acknowledgment as a leadership capacity. Nadav emphasizes seeing the human being across the disagreement.
28:18 — Belonging was a resource already present
Many students had independently described the faculty as a home or family. Dana says this existing attachment helped motivate participation. The lesson is not that a short intervention manufactures community from nothing: earlier relationships can support a response to crisis. Nadav connects this with the importance of investing in belonging before trouble occurs.
31:36 — Four subjects and transparent updates
The first meeting identified four themes: protected dialogue, closer relationships between Jewish and Arab students, how to open the academic year, and emotional support. A short update thanked participants, reflected the issues and invited others to join. Transparency continued throughout. The facilitators describe themselves as listening, learning and integrating, rather than asking a question whose answer they had already decided.
35:46 — Boundaries that protect expression
Dana describes using the aChord Center’s traffic-light model. Red statements included racism, threats and support for or incitement to terrorism: facilitators would stop them. Yellow or orange concerned potentially legitimate content expressed in a demeaning or insulting manner. Green could include uncomfortable criticism protected by freedom of expression. These were the process’s described boundaries, not a universal legal test. Emotional legitimacy did not mean every form of speech was permitted.
38:44 — Worktables turn needs into proposals
At the second meeting, participants worked on the themes with the needs identified earlier. Professional facilitators and mediation-trained student clinic graduates co-led tables after preparation. Proposals needed to answer those needs and fit the organisation: for example, a credit-bearing course on multicultural legal issues, rather than an unrelated outing. Participants developed ideas the organisers say they could not have created alone.
46:52 — From proposals to a working programme
The guests distinguish an ongoing, structured process from dialogue held only for appearances. A protected-dialogue team developed a charter emphasizing openness, sensitivity, education and discussion. The account describes trying to address disputes within the faculty before escalation, without presenting this as a prohibition on other remedies. A mixed Jewish–Arab course was planned for the following semester; its future status is preserved here as a plan, not a verified completed programme.
50:13 — Continuing support and the wider lesson
The faculty also designated contacts for emotional concerns and retained outside mediation for further disputes; Dana reported several matters already handled. The guests stress continuing personal outreach when participation becomes difficult, with the message that each voice matters. Nadav sees possible lessons for other communities, including urban renewal and collective communities. The transferable sequence is preparation, a shared question, listening, participation, clear boundaries and a concrete work plan—not a promise that every conflict will end the same way.
