Living Alongside Profound Loss, with Lilach Shem Tov and Dr. Eti Avelin — Episode 135

00:48 — A conversation that does not explain away tragedy

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri welcomes Lilach Shem Tov, whose children were murdered, and Dr. Eti Avelin, whom Lilach describes as one of the professionals who supported her. They discuss loss, writing, community and meaning without offering a reason the tragedy happened. It preserves personal experiences and reflective tools, without presenting them as a treatment plan or a standard every grieving person must meet.

03:11 — Her grief did not follow a simple calendar

Lilach describes steps forward and backward. In her account, the realization that her children would not return became especially acute between the third and fourth years. This was her experience, not a universal timetable or a prediction that others will feel grief only later. Dr. Avelin emphasizes being seen and finding people who can accompany the person. The story allows complexity rather than demanding immediate strength, orderly stages or a visible recovery.

04:17 — Writing before she thought of herself as an author

Writing became a way Lilach could give pain a form when she needed it. She describes her first book, whose Hebrew title translates roughly as “Flying Against the Laws of Nature,” and the courage involved in sharing work after not considering herself a writer. A reader’s strong response helped her recognize value in her voice. Neither publication nor praise is required to use writing; its usefulness here is her testimony, not proof that it works for everyone.

06:35 — Metaphors can accompany, not explain, suffering

Dr. Avelin reflects back the tools she hears in Lilach’s account and uses Joseph in the pit and a lotus emerging from difficult conditions as images. These are meaning-making metaphors. They do not imply that harm was necessary, beneficial in itself or deserved. Lilach connects the lotus with her own writing. Someone may find such an image helpful or choose a different language entirely; no spiritual interpretation is a condition of support.

10:19 — Other people’s words can add to the burden

Lilach speaks against judging people enduring extreme loss and, in the recording’s context, families affected by captivity and October 7. She recalls people avoiding her or being unable to remain nearby. The practical issue is the effect of the surrounding circle: who can see the person without requiring a tidy story? A disappointing response need not become another task the bereaved person must fix. Seek suitable people and set limits on hurtful contact.

14:21 — The chosen community began before the murders

A crucial clarification occurs when Nadav asks about the support network: Lilach says her community of divorced and separated people formed before the murders. She describes isolation during the separation, harmful stories spread about her, a move from a larger home and children missing invitations to play. She sought people who understood. Some remained and supported her afterward too. These are her recollections; finding another circle and setting boundaries were acts of agency, not responsibility for the harm done to her.

19:18 — Meaning is the first part of her model

Lilach calls her framework MAZAL, a Hebrew word whose letters she uses for meaning, memories and learning. Meaning gives practical direction: what matters to me now, what can I contribute, and what makes a next action worthwhile? She contrasts this with an earlier life carried by routine. The framework is hers, not a validated clinical scale, and a person does not need to find a grand purpose before deserving help or care.

20:10 — Memories: add more than one part of a story

She describes a different distressing event—not the murders—that occupied her mornings and nights. Deliberately recalling good memories from that period gradually changed her relationship with the experience. The distinction matters: she is not asking listeners to turn their children’s murder into a good memory. This is her account of balancing attention, not erasing facts or prescribing unsupervised trauma exposure. Difficult memory work may need appropriate professional support. Nor is the example an instruction to force anyone to revisit trauma.

24:03 — Learning and permission to choose an interest

Learning is the third letter. Lilach describes courses, creative cards and subjects that interested her rather than matched outsiders’ expectations. NLP and tarot appear as her personal interests; their mention does not establish therapeutic effectiveness. She keeps her children within her life while making room for other activities. Dr. Avelin’s reflection on bitterness and being heard similarly leaves room for painful emotions, rather than ordering someone to replace them with positive thoughts.

25:59 — Pain can be beside life rather than its whole weight

Lilach recalls that the tragedy occurred on her thirty-eighth birthday, shortly after her mother’s unexpected death. Difficult dates remain. Her images of a match lighting another match and light alongside darkness express small possibilities rather than total transformation. They do not make grief a failure of will.

29:21 — Rest, renewed distress and another book

After October 7, Lilach says old pain resurfaced and she struggled for months. Writing again became a path, this time into a novel rather than another autobiographical book. She describes intense engagement over several months and acknowledges needing rest. A small step may be writing, music or contact, but rest is not evidence of failing to move forward. Her goal orientation is individual: she explicitly resists applying one scheme to every person.

32:17 — Three supports to explore gently

Dr. Avelin discusses giving painful feelings room, identifying something that helps one come back from a difficult period, and stepping back to review the day without self-attack. Examples include writing, music and a trusted friend. A planned check-in can help some people; it is not a fixed time limit on grief or proof that someone should be able to switch pain off. Adapt any exercise to the person, and obtain suitable clinical help when needed rather than force it.

38:57 — A long, personal path to motherhood again

Lilach describes six years between deciding to become a mother again and her daughter’s birth, including thirteen fertility treatments and two pregnancy losses. She gave birth at forty-four. This is a personal account, not a fertility prognosis or an instruction to become a parent to heal. A memory of laughing together after getting off a Paris shuttle at the wrong hotel shows ordinary joy alongside loss. It does not replace the children who died or erase their place.

42:19 — Direction and an individual path

Nadav’s Alice-at-the-crossroads image asks where a person wants to go, while his chair metaphor describes a practitioner supporting the journey rather than deciding it. In joint work, shared aims precede individual needs and plans. Dr. Avelin closes with the Hebrew wordplay that each person has their own way through pain, and a poetic image of light entering without denying hurt. The invitation is company, attention and workable next steps, without forced forgiveness, a recovery deadline or a promise that every crisis produces growth.

Original episode audio in Hebrew

Listen on Spotify

Watch the original episode (Hebrew)

Read the original Hebrew episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content