Talking across political divides with Guy Meroz — Episode 163

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

A detailed translated guide to Nadav Nishri’s conversation with journalist and broadcaster Guy Meroz. The original recording is in Hebrew. Political assessments below are the speakers’ views at the time of recording.

00:00 — Entering a room where people disagree

Nadav opens with his disappointment that the sense of solidarity after 7 October did not put an end to social division. He invites Guy Meroz because, as someone identifying with the political left, Guy chose to appear on Israel’s Channel 14 among people whose views often differed sharply from his.

Nadav sees willingness to talk as courage. Guy’s experience immediately adds complexity: criticism came from fellow panellists and from people in his own political camp who believed he should not have gone there at all.

01:29 — An unplanned step, not an effortless mission

Guy says the move began with an interview and an invitation to return, rather than a grand strategy. He hesitated, discussed it at home and decided to continue. Live debate against several assertive voices requires concentration and can be stressful.

He does not promise reconciliation or claim that his convictions have dissolved. What matters to him is hearing another side and letting a large audience hear what he actually thinks. Viewers sometimes tell him they disagree with almost everything he says but appreciate that he comes.

04:13 — Cooperation that becomes concrete

Asked what might come from these encounters, Guy describes a volunteer-recognition initiative developed with Haredi partners connected to United Hatzalah. The idea is to give people who volunteer practical recognition from businesses, not just praise.

An airport image captures his motivation: a person receives an upgrade because of their contribution to society rather than their expensive credit card. The project illustrates how people can find a shared purpose without first settling political or religious disagreements. He describes its development as it stood when they recorded.

06:35 — A time bank instead of another argument

Another proposal is a time bank: contributing a professional service creates credit that can be exchanged for someone else’s time. A mediator and a hairdresser become examples of a network built around giving. It is an initiative Guy hopes to advance, not a service whose present operation is verified here.

He insists on a useful distinction: he is seeking cooperation with people who want similar things, rather than demanding that everyone unite into one identity.

08:52 — Fear as a media product

Guy argues that fear attracts audiences and can reward further escalation in television and politics. He includes the channel where he appears in this criticism. At the same time, he values hearing voices that he believes were previously underrepresented. The tension matters: pluralism and criticism of the way it is presented can coexist.

Nadav likewise objects to narrow opinion spaces in his own surroundings. Their point is not that all reporting is identical, but that a familiar camp can also discourage the curiosity it asks of others.

14:34 — Public disagreement comes home

The conversation turns to Guy’s partnership with Orly and the concern his television decision initially caused at home. He describes support developing over time, including after another challenging interview. He also recalls their earlier joint work and their current, more separate projects.

Nadav thanks them for a past television item about his first book on divorce. It is a reminder of another use of media: giving people access to social knowledge and possibilities they may not otherwise encounter.

17:35 — Recognising the cost of being ready to fight

Guy admits that repeated televised confrontation began spilling into arguments with friends and family. He attended an anger-management workshop. Meeting people from very different occupations showed him that difficulty with anger was not confined to one kind of person.

He does not claim complete success. The change is sometimes managing to wait before responding. Recognising the effect of his work and seeking help becomes part of staying in the conversation rather than pretending that resilience has no limits.

19:19 — Empathy, a pause and the swimming pool

One practice Guy describes is asking why another person has said something hurtful: what pain or pressure might lie behind it? Understanding can change a response without making the behaviour acceptable. Another is a “balcony break”: stepping away rather than reacting immediately. He notes that live television does not always allow this.

Nadav adds a swimming-pool image. A mediator’s steady presence can reduce the splashing and help people remain together in discomfort long enough to talk about where they want to go. This concerns the facilitator’s stance, not a rule that participants must suppress anger or speak politely before their needs count.

21:52 — Speaking is a skill, listening can move a position

Why do more artists not take similar opportunities? Guy points out that television is a profession: timing, experience and the ability to express a clear position under pressure matter. Exposure alone does not make someone ready for the setting.

He also distinguishes shouting from persuasion. He retains his fundamental opposition to occupation and control over another people, while saying he has changed his mind on particular points by listening, including questions about media treatment of different groups. Understanding another argument is not abandoning every conviction.

26:50 — Shared needs do not erase serious disputes

Nadav highlights familiar aims: children’s education, safety, earning a living and coming home. Guy resists treating political differences as insignificant. He invokes the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin to underline the stakes and violence that can surround them.

The exchange preserves a real disagreement between host and guest. Shared goals may give a conversation a foundation; they do not prove that every difference is small or that injustice disappears when people recognise common needs.

28:38 — Meeting people beyond a label

Nadav recalls bringing settlers to perform in Tel Aviv around the disengagement, through a project intended to introduce people before judging them. Guy recalls years directing a singing group in Alfei Menashe despite criticism from friends. These are examples of maintaining contact without sharing a political position.

Both question blanket refusals to enter another camp’s spaces. Guy is nevertheless unsure how far his own example can spread, and describes resistance from people who see participation itself as legitimising a platform. The episode does not turn one person’s choice into an obligation to join every debate.

33:32 — Technology, lost tone and community

Nadav observes how written messages can lose tone, expression and intention, making conflict easier to escalate. Voice or an actual conversation may restore information that text has removed, although the speakers also acknowledge that people differ in how they want to communicate.

They connect this to community. Nadav worries about loneliness and losing the networks that once helped contain conflict. His argument is for independence supported by relationships, rather than an instruction to return to an idealised past or sacrifice individuality. Technology can connect people as well as isolate them.

38:45 — Mediators and a future with many voices

Nadav asks mediators to see their skills as relevant beyond private disputes: creating contact, sustaining conversation and helping communities find purposes they can act on together. The speakers criticise experiences of the justice system, but do not offer a legal conclusion about any individual case.

Guy’s closing optimism draws on historical enemies who later found ways to talk. He also recognises red lines, so the invitation is to explore possibilities rather than promise every relationship can be repaired. Nadav wants a country with many opinions, where his own needs and those of Arab, Haredi, religious and other neighbours have room. Cooperation begins with common ground; it need not end in uniformity.

Listen to episode 163

Original Hebrew audio and video. This is an edited episode guide, not a verbatim transcript or an English recording.

Listen on Spotify

Read the original Hebrew episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content