Hamutal Gat on the Mediator’s Inner Work — Episode 169

00:00 — The person behind the mediation tools

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri welcomes Hamutal Gat, whose work includes family mediation, training, teaching and professional supervision. She describes more than thirty years in mediation after earlier work in social work and law. Their topic is not another technique for analysing the parties, but the mediator’s own contribution to what happens.

02:41 — Looking through the window, and turning the camera around

Hamutal compares familiar professional observation to looking outward through a window or standing behind a camera. Mediators study behaviour, interests and dynamics, use questions and reflection, and follow ethical standards. All of this is necessary, but does not reveal everything. The person doing the observing is also involved. Their patience, emotional state, assumptions and responses help shape the room. Nadav recognizes occasions when arriving tired or preoccupied affected his work even without an obviously inappropriate sentence.

06:03 — A mediation mindset is an aspiration, not a permanent state

The desired qualities include empathy, curiosity, flexibility, willingness to help and reduced judgement. Hamutal says no person maintains all of them perfectly all the time. Values, beliefs, memories and feelings come into the meeting with the professional. The point is not to pretend to leave one’s humanity outside, but to recognize where it helps and where it interferes. Awareness creates a possibility of response that denial does not.

07:55 — Difficult participants and the mediator’s responsibility

Someone who seems stubborn or preoccupied with a small point may provoke fatigue, fear or irritation in the mediator. It is easy to explain a difficult meeting entirely as a problem with “those people.” Hamutal asks what the mediator did in response and how that contributed. Nadav distinguishes responsibility for improving his own conduct from taking responsibility away from the participants. They remain answerable for what they say and do. Reflection adds a missing part of the picture; it does not explain every failure through the mediator alone.

14:53 — Recognizing judgement and a lapse of empathy

Hamutal challenges the idea that being professional means never having an immediate judgement. A view opposed to one’s values can produce an internal reaction before one has chosen it. Likewise, empathy is not equally available towards everyone at every moment. She uses the idea of an empathic failure to describe a moment when understanding becomes difficult. The useful question is what happened and how to return to curiosity, rather than conceal it to preserve an image of perfect neutrality. Understanding a person’s position does not require agreeing with it.

20:16 — Reflection turns experience into learning

A difficult moment can be uncomfortable to revisit, especially if the session eventually ended well. Hamutal encourages treating both successes and failures as learning material. Ask when patience shortened, what triggered a reaction and what alternative might have been possible. This requires enough professional confidence to admit limitations. Nadav welcomes learning from mistakes. Experience alone is not the same as examining experience; a repeated pattern may remain invisible until someone deliberately looks at it.

21:17 — Anchors, recent stories and first impressions

The conversation gives concrete examples of bias. A first financial figure can become an anchor for the entire discussion. A story may seem more plausible because similar incidents were heard recently. A pleasant impression may be mistaken for evidence of honesty or fairness. Personal emotional associations can also affect how a participant is heard. These examples invite mediators to check interpretation instead of assuming it is an objective picture. They are practical illustrations, not a method of diagnosing the participants.

23:49 — Values and the limit of one’s ability to work

Hamutal uses strongly conflicting values, including racist statements, to explore what a mediator notices internally. In an ordinary debate one might argue back; in mediation the task is to understand needs and feelings without endorsing the view. She also recognizes a limit: if a practitioner cannot listen, maintain the process or genuinely help, it may be right to stop or pass the case to someone else. Recognizing that boundary can be professional responsibility rather than defeat.

25:55 — Prepare for triggers and seek supervision

Before returning to an ongoing case, think about what has been difficult and what may activate a reaction again. Hamutal favours ongoing reflection and professional supervision, individually or in groups, not only a basic course certificate. She contrasts the support familiar in therapeutic professions with the uneven attention she sees in mediation. This is a recommendation for professional development, not a universal statement of registration law. Time, energy and resources need to be set aside for examining practice.

29:55 — Awareness during a session, and support afterwards

Real-time reflection means noticing both the room and oneself soon enough to adjust. Hamutal notes that this is demanding, especially early in practice; later discussion with a supervisor can help make sense of moments missed in the room. Nadav describes slowing his own pace and, later in the episode, the reassuring backing of co-mediation, using an image of a supportive hand behind him. Support is not another person adding force to an already charged encounter. It is a way not to carry the whole task alone.

35:46 — A genuine difference about AI and human presence

Hamutal is uncertain how far AI might go, even in simulating human communication. Nadav is more confident that embodied presence and a human community retain a distinct value. He describes work on an AI tool connected to his books and website, while separating information from holding a relationship process. The disagreement remains part of the conversation, rather than being resolved into a certainty. Their forecasts and descriptions are the views expressed in the episode, not a current performance comparison or a promise of tool availability.

48:41 — Two closing messages: see the other, and see yourself

For participants, Hamutal emphasizes how difficult and important it is to look beyond proving oneself right. Justice matters, but relationships, needs and future goals also deserve attention. A friend’s question about whether mediation would declare her right illustrates the difference between vindication and the process offered. For mediators, the message is to help people move in small steps without taking the decision from them. Patience and empathy are limited resources: professional growth includes repeatedly asking how one’s own reactions affect the people one is there to serve.

Original episode audio in Hebrew

Listen on Spotify

Watch the original episode (Hebrew)

Read the original Hebrew episode page

השאר תגובה

Skip to content