Severe conflict during separation — Nadav Nishri and Dr Inbal Kivenson Bar-On | Episode 31

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri speaks with Dr Inbal Kivenson Bar-On about severe parental conflict and children’s relationships. This detailed edited guide covers the first conversation only. The original recordings are in Hebrew; chapter times map the available source transcript, not synchronized translated captions.

Original Hebrew video — longer version

This YouTube recording is a longer version than the Spotify episode. The guide focuses on the first conversation only.

Watch on YouTube

Original Hebrew audio

Listen on Spotify

00:26 — An episode about severe conflict

Nadav Nishri introduces a difficult conversation about families that move into intense conflict during separation, including families that previously functioned reasonably well. His references to recent killings belong to the recording; the episode does not establish the dates, perpetrators or causes of particular crimes. The focus is preventing harm to children, not predicting that divorce leads to violence or permanent damage in every family.

01:52 — Introducing Dr Inbal Kivenson Bar-On

His guest is Dr Inbal Kivenson Bar-On, introduced as a social worker, university educator and court expert working with high-conflict families. Her University of Haifa profile confirms clinical social work, psychotherapy, parent–child work and parenting coordination. The program role mentioned at the recording should not be read as a current claim that she heads an entire university department. She says she has just come from three hours of questioning in court.

02:33 — Pressure on professionals

Nadav asks about pressure to change expert opinions. Inbal describes attacks, disparagement and competing economic, gender and political interests around this work, and the emotional endurance it demands. She emphasizes commitment to children in difficult circumstances and colleagues with a sense of mission. These are accounts of her professional experience, not findings against identified people or proof that disagreement with an expert is always intimidation.

03:53 — A parallel process of taking sides

Inbal sees a parallel between a family demanding complete loyalty and attacks on the professionals helping it. A person may be treated as either an ally or an enemy, with little room for complexity. Her point is to notice that dynamic without simply reversing it and labeling one parent wholly good and another wholly bad. Reasoned challenge, scrutiny and legitimate complaints remain different from harassment.

04:24 — Distress can matter without excusing harm

She explains that a parent influencing a child against the other may be genuinely frightened and distressed rather than acting from a simple wish to be cruel. That is why her approach includes working with that parent too. Understanding fear does not establish that every allegation is anxiety-driven, remove responsibility for harmful behavior or require contact where there is abuse or danger. Assessment must come before conclusions.

05:00 — The demand for a total coalition

She describes a stance of suspicion in which the child and helping agencies are expected to join one side completely. Anything less can be experienced as betrayal. The concern is pressure that leaves no room for the child’s own experience. It is not a checklist proving manipulation whenever a parent or child distrusts a professional or objects to a proposal.

05:22 — Holding mixed feelings: a Kleinian explanation

Inbal uses Melanie Klein’s contrast between the paranoid-schizoid position and the depressive position. In this theoretical language, sharply split good–bad thinking contrasts with holding complexity, sadness, longing and concern together. These are psychoanalytic positions, not a diagnosis of schizophrenia, psychosis or clinical depression in a listener or parent. Her practical emphasis is the professional’s capacity to remain thoughtful in the face of polarized demands.

06:13 — Can a response change the direction?

Nadav asks what someone can do before a difficult situation becomes entrenched. He believes how the other person responds may affect escalation. This offers room for practical choice, not responsibility for controlling someone else’s behavior or proof that sufficient calm stops violence. Necessary protection, specialist assessment and legal advice can be needed alongside efforts to communicate.

07:07 — Fear of the worst can also keep people stuck

He notes that some people remain in unhappy relationships because they fear an extreme separation. Inbal hopes awareness of the cliff edge can help people seek support earlier and avoid taking the children into a destructive struggle. Neither staying nor leaving should be prescribed from a podcast. Fear needs a safe place to be understood, especially when coercion or violence may be present.

07:54 — Harm can be communicated without visible injury

Inbal describes subtle ways a parent’s anxiety or anger can reach a child: tone, posture, contempt for the other parent and emotional atmosphere, not only explicit statements. She worries about a parent filling the child’s inner world with the parent’s own feelings. The description calls for careful attention; it does not mean tone alone establishes abuse or that every child’s reluctance comes from parental influence.

08:32 — A child should not have to carry a parent

She says love for a child can coexist with a parent’s great need for reassurance or an ally. She wants families to receive help earlier, ideally before reaching her most difficult court-related cases. Children need space for their own feelings rather than the job of stabilizing an adult. Support for the parent is part of protecting that space, without asking the child to diagnose or manage the parent.

08:44 — A direction for children and parents

Inbal describes building a process from the start around what the family wants for the children and for the parents, including how to explain the change. In Nadav’s method a common-goal foundation comes first, then the personal needs and practical issues within it. This does not require agreeing on everything, becoming friends or bypassing facts about harm. The participants need an appropriate, safe process.

09:29 — Helping children make sense of the story

Children may fill gaps in their understanding with frightening explanations, including assuming something is their fault. Inbal advocates language that gives meaning and an adult who can guide parents in their own adjustment, communication with each other and conversations with children. It is not a demand for children to hear adult accusations or every intimate detail. Explanations should fit their age and circumstances.

09:55 — Notice when anger is growing

She describes family members or professionals giving advice about what to do to the other person, with anger growing like an expanding desert tumbleweed. That is a moment to stop and seek help rather than add another retaliatory step. Her image concerns escalation, not a rule that all anger is wrong or that urgent action must wait until a person is calm.

10:35 — Grief and fear are not reducible to money

Nadav insists that separation includes grief and pain, not simply a financial negotiation. Inbal adds that money can also symbolize power, status, control or superiority, and adversarial language may intensify fights about money or parenting time. These are possible meanings, not reasons to dismiss actual housing costs, livelihood, child support or enforceable rights as merely emotional symbols.

11:58 — A critique of immediately turning everything legal

Nadav questions the reflex of sending people straight from therapy into competing legal advice without support for fear and loss. His strong criticism should not become a claim that legal advice inherently creates conflict or should be avoided. Nor are property always automatically divided equally or parenting powers unlimited. Practical rights, legal safeguards and emotional support can be considered together rather than made rival choices.

13:05 — A particularly vulnerable moment

Inbal says people early in separation may be susceptible to influence and exploitation because they do not know their financial future, whether they will find another relationship or how their children will fare. Friends and relatives can protect space for thought rather than recruit them into a campaign. These concerns are real; vulnerability does not mean an adult is incapable of deciding or that every adviser is exploiting them.

14:05 — When a functioning family becomes entrenched

She reports seeing families that previously functioned well become caught in long disputes and refers generally to research without identifying a particular study. Sometimes she enters after seven or ten years of litigation. These are her case experiences and a warning, not a measured prediction that ordinary families will inevitably collapse or that every lengthy case has the same cause.

14:40 — Stress, learning and time to recover

Inbal describes persistent alertness, with children repeatedly feeling under attack and having little opportunity to settle. She connects that with reduced energy for learning, exploration, enjoyment and reading social situations. Trauma resources support taking chronic threat seriously, but this does not diagnose every child of separation or establish irreversible damage. Risk, response and recovery vary; safety and appropriate support matter.

16:09 — Too many encounters can add a burden

She describes repeated assessments, treatments, children being heard in court and social-work encounters, all possibly involving well-intentioned professionals. The concern is cumulative stress and a lack of recovery time. It is not a recommendation to avoid necessary medical care, child-protection assessment, a child’s right to be heard or all court involvement. Coordination and proportionality are more useful than indiscriminately adding or rejecting services.

16:39 — Distress and advice in online groups

Nadav worries that the loudest online voices may be people in great distress, sometimes urging others to attack. He speculates about why frightening stories become influential. A social-media post does not reveal a person’s diagnosis or motives, and the discussion is not evidence that every account of harm is exaggerated. A friend can offer compassion while encouraging relevant, reliable advice rather than repeating another family’s battle plan.

18:41 — What they mean by legal abuse

Inbal describes using legal processes to exhaust or hurt the other parent under the cover of legitimate proceedings. They discuss serious costs and a threatening reference to a large payment, including two hundred thousand shekels, without establishing a documented transaction or current fee. The concept points to possible misuse of a process; making a lawful application, reporting harm or disagreeing with an expert is not by itself abuse.

19:39 — Lawyers can help calm a case

Inbal explicitly values lawyers who regulate and support parents. She recalls successful work to restore a relationship with help from a guardian ad litem and lawyers using a consistent language of responsibility and calming. This is an account of collaboration, not a success rate or a coalition meant to silence the child. Independent roles, evidence and the child’s safety and views still need to be respected.

20:30 — Choosing representation and asking about the approach

They describe an adversarial system while distinguishing a lawyer who promotes dialogue from one who escalates every dispute. A client can ask about objectives, negotiation and a strategy that protects rights without automatically intensifying conflict. Even if the other person is confrontational, a suitable response need not mirror every attack. That is not a promise one cooperative lawyer can prevent all harm or that protective litigation is illegitimate.

21:36 — Fees and incentives deserve clear questions

They consider paying a full fee in advance versus paying per hearing, case or application and wonder how this affects incentives. This is their discussion, not established research proving that one model reliably ends conflict or that advance payment is financially safer. Scope, services, likely total cost, termination and refund terms, independence and professional duties need clarity. Do not select or prepay a lawyer solely on this generalization.

22:12 — False statements, and an important refusal to generalize

They discuss allegations and stories later found untrue. Nadav makes a broader remark about people being advised to lie; Inbal explicitly says she would not put it that way. She also sees lawyers offering constructive advice that clients do not follow. Preserve this disagreement: no presumption that all complaints are false, all lawyers encourage dishonesty or a report of violence should be dismissed without assessment.

23:33 — Support a relative rather than finance a battle

The appeal to grandparents, siblings and friends is to comfort a person in crisis rather than automatically fund retaliation. It does not require affection or discourage paying for necessary representation, housing, care or protection. A supportive circle can help someone think, rest and seek suitable advice, without deciding the case for them or turning children into messengers.

24:04 — When court authority may be necessary

Inbal qualifies the preference for dialogue: when contact has broken down and a parent will not engage in appropriate joint work, court involvement can matter. She describes judicial authority and tools that voluntary help lacks. Actual orders depend on jurisdiction, facts, child welfare, evidence and lawful powers; a podcast does not authorize compulsory treatment or guarantee a particular sanction. Urgent protection need not wait for failed mediation.

24:46 — A more therapeutic use of legal authority

She discusses efforts to develop a therapeutic court approach and refers to models in the United States and Australia, including referrals to financial advice or emotional and relationship support. These are her recording-era descriptions and proposals, not a verified account of every country’s current system or evidence that each model works equally well. A court-directed intervention should remain individually assessed, safe and proportionate.

25:25 — Beyond good parent and bad parent

They reject a simple division into good and bad people. Inbal emphasizes relationship history, the child’s age and developmental stage, life circumstances and the legal process itself. A parent may need help as well as accountability. Complexity does not make abuse a mutual disagreement, and respecting a person does not require discounting evidence of risk.

26:10 — A call from the rabbinical court

Nadav recalls a woman with a baby being urged by telephone to open a case quickly, without understanding why, then calling him. He sees the story as a reason to ask questions before being hurried into a process. It is an anecdote, not an instruction to leave a court, miss a hearing or deadline, withdraw an application or delay urgent protection. Appropriate legal advice can explain the consequences.

26:55 — Prompt assessment rather than a label-driven rush

Nadav suggests consulting someone experienced in these family dynamics before escalating because one suspects alienation. Inbal agrees that preliminary steps can matter. Consultation is not a compulsory permission slip from a therapist before approaching court, police or protection services. Prompt action and thoughtful assessment can coexist; danger or an expiring deadline cannot be assumed safe to postpone.

27:28 — Not every loss of contact has the same explanation

Inbal explicitly distinguishes alienating influence from other situations: adolescence, a child overwhelmed by the fighting who chooses a quieter side, or a parent who has actually harmed the child. She also mentions exposure to infidelity or adult messages as a possible source of distress. These examples require understanding the child’s experience; none proves one cause automatically or justifies forcing contact before safety is assessed.

28:45 — Do not make alienation a magic diagnosis

She worries the term parental alienation has become a golden buzzer in legal conflict and is too readily linked to labels such as narcissistic or borderline. WHO does not recognize parental alienation as an ICD-11 health diagnosis. Contact problems need individual assessment of multiple possible causes. The term should neither decide the case by itself nor discredit a child or parent reporting abuse.

29:19 — Scrutiny is different from intimidation

They return to experts being attacked through accessible email, messaging and media channels and the difficulty of working in this area. Inbal says feelings can be treated as facts when a professional is undermined. Her experience does not establish that all professional opinions are correct or all complaints malicious. Transparent reasoning, lawful review and accountability belong alongside protection from threats.

30:44 — Mediation can fail; other cooperative routes exist

Nadav acknowledges that not every mediation succeeds and mentions collaborative divorce and an earlier conversation with Idit Shahar. No unverified link to that episode is supplied. His preference for cooperative work does not remove the need for legal rights or courts in unsuitable cases. Failure of one process is not proof the family is beyond help or that someone has failed morally.

31:17 — A child can behave differently inside and outside the room

Inbal describes a child briefly showing affection and longing with a parent in a session, then becoming rigid and hostile outside. She finds that painful and interprets it within the dynamics she treats. The pattern alone does not prove coercion or identify a guilty parent: context, safety, relationship history and the child’s account still matter. Do not use the anecdote to override an individual assessment.

32:17 — An extreme-case experience is not a causal study

They say the extreme cases known to them had entered legal proceedings and contrast these with mediation. Nadav refers to hundreds of families. This is their experience, not a representative comparison proving litigation causes every severe conflict or mediation prevents all of them. Appropriate judicial protection can be necessary, and constructive mediation depends on circumstances rather than a guaranteed protective effect.

32:54 — Children are not the glue for an adult’s broken pieces

Inbal asks parents not to make the child stabilize their own distress through accusations that the other parent is abandoning, dangerous or frightening. She wants adults to recognize what the child values in a parent. This does not require telling a child an unsafe person is safe or denying actual abandonment or abuse. Supportive language should be truthful, age-appropriate and protective.

33:39 — Cut photographs, and the image of internal organs

She recalls families cutting the other parent out of photographs or magnets and compares erasing a parent with taking a child’s heart or lungs. Nadav adds the image of being fifty percent of a parent. These are emotional metaphors about belonging, not literal physiology, a definition of every family or proof that any protected separation is harmful. Avoid denigration without ignoring real risk.

34:10 — Repair and the possible benefits of separation

Inbal favors working on difficulties rather than erasing people, and notes possible benefits: children may rest from arguments, experience other family models and receive support from more people. The aim is repair and workable communication when appropriate. It is not a duty to unblock unsafe contact, reconcile or become friends, nor a promise that all children benefit from divorce in the same way.

35:13 — A world that can hold imperfection

She contrasts development around a wholly good and wholly bad parent with recognizing imperfect people and speaking about anger and loss. Her psychoanalytic concern about later development is not a prediction that a child will acquire a personality disorder. Integration does not require treating both parents’ behavior as equally safe or equally harmful. A child can need both meaningful relationships and protection.

36:13 — Passive words can hide a more complex situation

She describes a parent saying the child may go if they want, while in her interpretation doing nothing to support a relationship or silently reinforcing resistance. This is one possible pattern, not proof that every respectful response to a child’s reluctance is manipulation. A child’s views, age, actual experiences and safety must be understood rather than dismissed as somebody else’s script.

36:44 — Hostility is a reason to understand and help

Inbal says some parents find a child’s hostility during contact even more painful than no contact. She describes fear, pressure to choose and a hostile image of the other parent. These are dynamics she encounters, not a diagnosis based on one angry exchange or a rule that distressed children are unnatural. Appropriate help should attend to the child without making the child the enemy.

37:14 — The cult comparison has limits

She compares psychological control and dependency with her earlier work involving children in cults, and warns against simply waiting for spontaneous recovery. The episode supplies no recovery dataset establishing that children never improve without a specific intervention. The comparison is her way of conveying pressure and dependency, not a finding that every family is a cult or a justification for coercive removal or an unassessed treatment.

37:34 — A child cannot negotiate on equal terms with a parent

Inbal emphasizes the unequal dependence between children and adults. She evokes a child unable to challenge a family account even about whether a parent attended a bar mitzvah. The concern is preserving room for the child’s actual memories and experience. A discrepancy needs careful exploration; it does not by itself prove fabricated memories or identify who is truthful.

38:21 — Do not exploit trust or denigrate a whole family

They ask adults not to use the child’s trust to disparage another parent’s personality, interests or extended family. Inbal asks why a break with a parent may spread to grandparents, uncles, aunts and cousins. That is a question for assessment, not an automatic diagnostic sign: wider contact can also have its own history and safety considerations. Children should not carry an adult’s campaign.

39:25 — Pausing, and making the situation understandable

Nadav says he needs to breathe and they pause before closing. He recalls valuing Inbal’s earlier point about making separation understandable to children rather than catastrophizing it. Normalizing a change does not mean normalizing violence or making children conceal fear. This pause is part of their conversation, not a prescribed breathing exercise or evidence of a medical effect.

41:01 — Hope without a success-rate promise

Near the close, Nadav mentions ninety-five percent and says most people who have room to talk can succeed. No denominator, period, outcome definition or independent evaluation is supplied, so the figure is not a verified current success rate. His provocative remark that a couple has not suffered enough is not a requirement to endure more pain or accept a settlement. Choosing whether to continue belongs to the participants.

41:49 — Share help, with room for rights and safety

They close by encouraging people to understand consequences, seek suitable advice and share information, hoping fewer families reach severe conflict. Social channels, books and availability invitations belong to the recording rather than a checked current service. They thank each other, listeners and Sharon. The aim is earlier support and less harm, without making reconciliation, direct contact or any particular agreement compulsory.

Sources and context

השאר תגובה

Skip to content