Crisis, meaning and a future after war — Nadav Nishri and Daniel Harush | Episode 76

00:00 — Returning to a conversation after October 7

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Nadav Nishri and fellow mediator Daniel Harush discuss personal and national crisis during the war following October 7. A planned return to recorded episodes on October 8 had been overtaken by events. They speak about getting out of bed, caring for children, working and finding a direction when ordinary routines collapse. This guide preserves their personal accounts, political disagreements and practical examples; their experiences are not a treatment programme or a promise that crisis necessarily produces growth.

Original Hebrew video

Watch on YouTube

Original Hebrew audio

Listen on Spotify

02:52 — Even people outside the front can struggle

Daniel describes the psychological strain on people who are neither fighting nor directly exposed to the atrocities. He asks how a mediator can be available to others while overwhelmed himself. His language of “energy” refers to presence and activation: like a flame, it can sometimes be raised and sometimes lowered. It does not mean a medically established energy field, and preparation by the mediator does not require participants to suppress their feelings.

04:55 — Preparing to be present

Before difficult meetings Daniel tries to limit news, meditate, listen to music in the car and spend less time on his phone. During the war he was pulled back into constant updates and noticed their effects on his body and mood. First he acknowledged what was happening without judging himself; only then could he choose a small change. A difficult day after a better one does not mean that every effort has failed.

06:33 — Contribution need not look the same for everyone

Cooking for soldiers, donating and helping directly are meaningful responses, but Daniel also values preserving enough capacity to help later. Preparing for professional service can itself be a contribution. The comparison is not a competition over who is useful. Rest, practical support and professional care may be needed; neither speaker’s preferred routine should become a demand for immediate productivity from somebody in acute distress.

07:08 — Nadav’s boundaries around images

Nadav says he had long avoided television news and violent entertainment, including Game of Thrones. He criticises media incentives to capture attention, rather than establishing that every report is false. Two of his brothers were involved in the war; he did not need repeated graphic posts to know terrible events had occurred. He describes closing such posts and limiting contacts that circulated them while remaining concerned and informed.

09:24 — Knowing is different from watching everything

Daniel asks whether limiting exposure means not knowing what is happening. Nadav distinguishes obtaining necessary information from repeatedly watching violent images. He thinks about his responsibility towards his daughters and his ability to remain present. This is an invitation to choose an information diet, not to ignore danger, reliable reporting or official safety instructions. Reading short updates and checking sources can coexist with keeping distressing videos off the screen.

10:13 — The black-box metaphor and a family in shelters

Nadav imagines an enormous black box of pain that cannot be processed all at once. He favours gradual, chosen exposure and compares reading with watching. His family also ran to protected spaces under rocket fire, and he says his daughters were coping reasonably at that time; this is one family’s account, not evidence that the same approach protects every child. Today’s scale of civilian exposure can be overwhelming without being the first such exposure in history. Sadness still has a place.

12:33 — War, separation and limited agency

Nadav particularly recognises parents managing separation during the war and trying to care for their children. Responsibility does not mean total control, superiority over other parents or an obligation to look calm. Friends and relatives may be hurt, circumstances may change, and adults may need help themselves. The useful question is what can be supported or influenced now, rather than who should have been strong enough to avoid suffering.

13:41 — Frankl: meaning without rewriting his history

Nadav turns to Viktor Frankl and Man’s Search for Meaning as an example of finding a direction under extreme suffering. The Austrian psychiatrist lost his first wife and other close relatives; his manuscript was taken from him at Auschwitz. The recording’s account of deported children is inaccurate: the Nazis had forced the couple to terminate a pregnancy. Meaning was important in Frankl’s account, but did not guarantee survival or make victims responsible for dying. The familiar “space between stimulus and response” wording is not a verified quotation by Frankl.

Historical reference · Quotation clarification

16:23 — Not everyone can use the same coping method

Daniel regards Nadav’s ability to limit exposure as unusual in his own circle, not as a measured population finding. He recalls an unnamed psychiatrist criticising compulsive consumption of hostage-return videos. Their practical distinction is between caring about people and watching every image of them. Choosing not to watch does not establish indifference; equally, someone who finds the boundary difficult should not be shamed or expected to copy Nadav immediately.

17:45 — Repeated checking can feel like control

They discuss the pull of updates, the wish to belong and the feeling that checking gives control. Daniel’s biological explanation of “addiction to stress” should not be treated as a diagnosis or a universal hormonal mechanism. Notice whether a habit is affecting sleep, dreams, relationships or irritability. A small, supported change may help. Being harmed by the war is real; their talk of agency does not mean people chose the war or their suffering.

19:15 — Information, responsibility and help

Reducing an endless feed is different from assuming important information will always reach you automatically. Keep reliable safety alerts and the updates your situation requires. Nadav’s criticism of political leadership expresses his view at the time; democratic accountability is not something one person can complete from a sofa. Responsibility towards children can include seeking family, community, public or professional support rather than carrying every task alone.

20:47 — Learning during an interruption

Nadav describes experimenting with artificial-intelligence tools, building multilingual educational material and finding new skills when work was disrupted. He sees possible opportunities for rebuilding after a crisis. War does not inevitably bring prosperity, and learning a tool does not guarantee income. These are examples of something he could try, alongside the very real human and economic costs, not a claim that war is beneficial.

23:43 — The financial pressure is not imaginary

They acknowledge self-employed people who suddenly have no income but still owe suppliers, employees or other creditors. Grants may be delayed or uncertain. Taking a course, listening to a podcast or experimenting can be useful when feasible, yet does not pay every debt or replace assistance. Nobody must turn acute hardship into a business opportunity on command. Asking for practical help and resting can also be responsible choices.

24:22 — Daniel challenges the invitation to plan

Daniel asks how people can plan a future after homes were invaded and basic security collapsed, even when they were not directly attacked. Nadav answers with care for children and continued learning as possible anchors. His comments about changing professions are not a claim that all qualifications have become unnecessary. Nor should confidence in charity be read as proof that nobody experiences hunger or unmet needs. The challenge and the answer remain distinct: hope is not an instruction to stop being distressed.

28:07 — Mutual aid and different ways of functioning

They recognise support for survivors, evacuees and hostage families, including people from Be’eri and Kfar Aza. Nadav praises his friend Moran Nehemia’s work in the Bnei Shimon support network as he knew it then. He describes his own hyperactivity and ADHD in personal terms and explicitly does not expect everyone to function as he does. Helping, seeking help and preserving capacity can take different forms.

30:36 — A course becomes a fourth book

Nadav recounts a Hebrew mediation course first recorded during the COVID period, later rewritten and expanded into multilingual learning material and the work on his fourth book. He describes soft and hard negotiation and individualist and collectivist approaches within his New Partnership thinking. These are projects in progress at the recording, not a claim about a present publication or course offer. Studying mediation can also be useful outside a professional career.

31:04 — People make the opportunity, not the mediator

The course is described as free at that time, rather than promised as a current offer. Daniel stresses that the people in a crisis create their own possibilities; a mediator helps them explore rather than decides for them. That raises the national question: can a larger conflict also contain possibilities? In practical mediation, shared future aims provide a foundation for clarifying personal needs, while early personal listening and painful feelings remain legitimate.

33:37 — Peace as a political possibility

Nadav argues for a long-term future involving education, dialogue and relationships alongside security. His view that walls and checkpoints alone are insufficient is a political argument, not a finding that a specific policy would certainly have prevented October 7. His remarks about Gaza, Egypt and the region are not a legal determination of territory or blockade status. The possibility he wants explored is more substantial than an immediate exchange of boundaries.

35:08 — Different frameworks without erasing people

Nadav uses individualist and collectivist frameworks to discuss religious and political conflict. These should not be turned into fixed characteristics of all Jews or Muslims. He says coexistence cannot be based on erasing either Islam or Judaism. He takes a strong position against Hamas while distinguishing an organisation and its rule from Palestinian civilians. Long-range references to fifty or a hundred years express his outlook, not predictions or permission for collective harm.

37:04 — An explicit disagreement about leadership

Nadav considers whether Benjamin Netanyahu could have sufficient legitimacy to advance peace. Daniel questions that legitimacy in the circumstances of the recording. The disagreement matters: they do not present a single agreed judgement about the leader. Their claims concern the political moment in which they spoke, not a description of the government or officeholders today. Hope for leadership change is an opinion rather than an established forecast.

37:55 — Hope, attacks and damaged trust

Daniel remembers the hope around Oslo and Israeli–Palestinian encounters, followed by attacks that damaged trust. They compare this with outside events that reignite mistrust while a mediation is progressing. Nadav argues that a civilian dialogue channel is needed alongside security. His account of dialogue’s absence is an interpretation, not proof of a single cause of the massacre. Neither a past failure nor a hopeful analogy resolves the practical safety questions automatically.

40:21 — Daniel objects to dismissing annihilation rhetoric

When Nadav speaks about anger and extremism, Daniel insists that some people really do voice calls for annihilation. They reject killing Palestinian children and civilians. Their exchange should not be flattened into a claim that all extreme language is harmless frustration. Nadav distinguishes voicing political views in this podcast from imposing them on mediation participants. Seeing a neighbour’s humanity does not require agreement, friendship, unsafe contact or surrendering protection.

42:51 — The human conversation before a mechanical answer

Daniel describes mediation sessions spent hearing feelings and the past before a tangible solution appears. That time may help build trust rather than constitute a failed session. A person who initiated separation may also be hurt or frightened. Recognition can coexist with anger and disagreement. Shared aims do not require a shared romantic future, and the mediator’s task is to support participants’ choices, not require emotional closure before practical work begins.

45:01 — South Africa: hope with accurate history

The speakers use Nelson Mandela and South Africa as a hopeful analogy. Mandela spent twenty-seven years imprisoned, became president in 1994, and received the Nobel Peace Prize jointly with F. W. de Klerk in 1993, before the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. These details correct the recording’s compressed account. A transition involving profound inequality cannot be reduced to stereotypes about the ability or character of Black and white populations.

Historical reference

46:23 — Fear of change and the limits of an analogy

Nadav recalls working with a South African volunteer named Alan while living in a caravan at Dugit Beach on Lake Kinneret; the story illustrates fear of Mandela’s rise. It is an individual’s recollection, not a description of all South Africans or an endorsement of his comparison with Arafat. The commission later combined testimony, investigation and a conditional amnesty process, requiring full disclosure and a political objective under law. Confession did not automatically produce amnesty, forgiveness or an embrace from victims’ relatives.

Official commission framework

48:56 — Reconciliation is not compulsory forgiveness

The South African example supports asking how a future can be built without pretending the past did not happen. It does not establish that every victim forgave, that justice is unnecessary or that the same institution can simply be copied into another conflict. The conversation also recalls Rabbi Menachem Froman’s dialogue-oriented outlook. Any future relationship must leave room for safety, accountability, different beliefs and each person’s freedom not to forgive.

49:20 — What happens the day after destructive slogans?

Daniel challenges calls to turn Gaza into a parking lot by asking what happens afterwards and what such a wish means for human beings. He is criticising that rhetoric, not recommending it. They discuss hostility towards joint bereaved-family memorial events and a children’s-story image of hatred passed down through generations. Claims about the size of extremist minorities are their impressions, not verified population statistics. Their point is to ask what kind of life the next generation can have.

51:43 — Reciprocity: useful question, limited model

Nadav invokes Robert Axelrod’s cooperation research. In the studied repeated-game strategy, Tit for Tat starts by cooperating and then copies the other player’s previous move; it is not “two good moves for one good move” or unlimited retaliation. Its tournament success depends on a model and conditions, not a proof of the best policy in every war. The useful question is how clear, proportionate responses and opportunities for renewed cooperation might change a relationship.

Original research

53:22 — Political hopes retain uncertainty

They call for leadership able to imagine a different future, including younger generations. Nadav links regional diplomatic possibilities with his interpretation of the attack and its aftermath; this is not an established explanation of perpetrators’ motives. Early wartime casualty estimates in the recording should not be used as current figures. Nadav hopes peace could still become possible while doubting the present leadership, and explicitly allows that his judgement could be wrong.

54:44 — Grief and continuing bonds

Daniel describes a friend grieving her father and struggling to let go. The question is not a test of when grief should end. Nadav imagines wanting his own relatives to remember him, perhaps with a bench or a visit to a grave, while continuing to live and find joy. This is his personal wish, not an instruction to stop mourning, break a bond or judge someone whose grief is different.

56:16 — Displacement, public argument and ordinary life

Nadav names northern places connected to his childhood, including Dafna, Sha’ar Yashuv, HaGoshrim and Kiryat Shmona. He speaks about displacement and people now nearby in Tel Aviv, expressing criticism of leadership at that historical moment. Daniel describes hostility towards opinions on social media. Disagreement should address a position rather than become personal abuse. Neither remaining in Israel nor considering life elsewhere becomes a moral test imposed on other families.

58:12 — A family WhatsApp glimpse of normality

Nadav compares shelter updates from himself, his mother and his sister with everyday videos from family in the United States. His brother Assi in Manhattan makes chocolate balls with his daughter and goes to a park; his sister Keren in Pennsylvania shares a child’s orchestra appearing at a football stadium. He mentions different branches of a large family and his mother’s return from New York. The contrast expresses longing for ordinary life, not proof that every life abroad is safe or a recommendation that everybody emigrate.

1:00:37 — An invitation to keep a future in view

Daniel recalls the peace hopes of the 1990s and constructive possibilities within Jewish prayer and interpretation. Neither claims all traditions or believers share one political view. Talking has helped them personally; listeners may find a useful question, a boundary around news, a way to help or someone to ask for support. Caring for children and for adults includes mothers as well as fathers. No one has to manufacture optimism, friendship or recovery on a timetable.

Read the original Hebrew episode

השאר תגובה

Skip to content