Episode 80: Hope and a different future after war — Daniel Harush with Anat Saragusti

0:01 — A coffee shop, the hostage photographs and a difficult introduction

Something with Mediation — Nadav Nishri

Daniel Harush interviews journalist and photographer Anat Saragusti in the special future-after-war edition of Something with Mediation. Daniel is the host; Nadav Nishri does not participate in this conversation. The recording is in Hebrew. Daniel describes seeing a photograph and memorial candles for a young barista he remembered, then passing hostage photographs at Rabin Square. Those ordinary encounters make it difficult to lift his head, yet he wants to ask about hope. Anat answers his opening question about how she is doing with an unvarnished account of feeling terrible.

Original recording in Hebrew — Spotify

Listen on Spotify

Original video in Hebrew — YouTube

2:23 — Experience does not cancel grief

Daniel introduces Anat’s roughly four decades documenting Israeli life through photography, writing and civil-society work. He seeks perspective when his own vision feels narrowed. Anat expects life to continue, but with enduring wounds: the shock damaged confidence in military protection, technology and assumptions of superiority. She also links it to the preceding nine months of political struggle over judicial changes, which she characterizes as an attempted regime coup. These are her interpretations of that period, not a diagnosis of every person or an up-to-date security assessment. Continuing life need not mean that loss has been resolved.

6:32 — From a childhood national story to a desired future

Anat recalls being taught that Israel wanted peace and was surrounded by enemies, then coming to question that simple division into good and bad. Daniel draws an analogy with couples whose shared lives have been shaken: imagine a good life five years ahead, then work backwards to practical steps. He is asking for aspiration, not a prediction. His positive observations from mediation do not mean that every family recovers easily or that children’s injuries can be dismissed as scars one simply lives with.

9:10 — Pessimism, action and the memory of 1973

Anat describes herself as both pessimistic and optimistic: continuing to struggle for change contains some belief that change is possible. She served on the Golan Heights in the Yom Kippur War and says its failures shaped her worldview. Sadat’s visit and the later peace treaty with Egypt became, for her, an example of moving beyond defeat and despair. The treaty was signed in 1979; its historical value does not make the present conflict identical, and she explicitly rejects imagining Sinwar simply replaying Sadat’s role. A crisis can open possibilities without being good or guaranteeing growth.

12:22 — Anat’s five-year proposal

Daniel again asks her to describe the hopeful picture rather than the likely one. Anat proposes a demilitarized Gaza, departure of Hamas leaders and an internationally backed reconstruction effort. She recalls watching the PLO leadership leave Beirut by ship in 1982 as an image, not proof that the same arrangement is available now. She imagines a US-led forum with European and regional partners, including countries associated with the Abraham Accords and Saudi Arabia, rebuilding civic society, political institutions and everyday life. Saudi participation is her proposal, not a claim that it had joined those accords.

13:29 — Reconstruction, constitutional change and the West Bank

Anat invokes postwar European reconstruction and changes in Germany and Japan as analogies for sustained international involvement. Historically, the Marshall Plan was a European recovery programme; Japan’s postwar occupation and constitutional reforms were a distinct process. Her comparison should not merge them into one programme or assume identical rules on rearmament. She insists that a Palestinian solution must include the West Bank rather than split it arbitrarily from Gaza, with demilitarization and strong international guarantees in her proposed framework. These are political proposals at the time of recording, not an agreed settlement or a guaranteed path to prosperity.

15:34 — Meeting Arafat in Beirut

Daniel asks about Anat’s 1982 encounter with Arafat alongside Uri Avnery, emphasizing his own preference to talk with someone willing to talk rather than leave them an unseen demon. Anat recalls being a young photographer with about two years’ experience, recognizing a major professional opportunity while crossing from east to besieged west Beirut. She corrects Daniel’s suggestion about a legal ban already applying: her recollection is that the specific prohibition followed later. She also describes the encounter as an early Israeli interview with Arafat. These historical recollections are not current advice about lawful contacts or proof of a single cause for subsequent legislation.

18:03 — Seeing a person does not erase propaganda or responsibility

Anat felt Arafat understood the media and was using the encounter to send a political message. Seeing an ordinary-looking person differed from public demonization, without erasing his organization’s history of violence. She contrasts his political time horizon with the religious, eternity-oriented outlook she attributes to Sinwar and some Israeli messianic currents. This is her analysis, not a verified reading of anyone’s mind or a claim that religious people cannot negotiate. Later in the conversation she explicitly recognizes religious people who work to connect communities.

21:05 — Concern about inflammatory language entering the mainstream

Daniel fears that extreme ideas are becoming acceptable beyond the political margins. He cites a clip by musician Idan Raichel and interprets it in exceptionally grave terms; the clip has not been independently reviewed here, and that interpretation is not presented as a verified statement of the musician’s intention or a legal finding. Anat and Daniel discuss the responsibility of people with audiences. They hope most people want family life and ordinary security, but do not provide polling that establishes this. Their central concern is how to resist dehumanization while still acknowledging threats.

22:35 — A difficult self-critique of the peace camp

Daniel asks what their own camp got wrong rather than only blaming others. Anat criticizes normalization of settlement expansion, extremist politics and what she sees as policies of strengthening Hamas to weaken rival Palestinian leadership. She recalls reporting in Gaza in 1987 and argues that governments across political camps avoided a strategic decision about the territories. These are her historical-political claims, not independently established proof of each government’s motives. Her account of secular Palestinian movements and people who admired Israeli democracy should not be read as certifying every organization as consistently democratic or nonviolent.

26:10 — Language, avoided questions and women’s exclusion

Anat argues that labels such as West Bank versus Judea and Samaria and settlers versus residents shape perception. She criticizes a government approach of discussing matters on which 70% could agree while leaving the territorial question aside; that percentage describes a recalled political formula, not a fresh poll. She also criticizes cooperation with parties that exclude women. In her view, excluding half the population narrows attention to militarized national security and neglects personal security, education, welfare and children. She explicitly acknowledges generalizing and that men can hold more complex perspectives; this is not a biological claim about all men or women.

29:18 — The neighbours are people, not a category without faces

Daniel asks how to respond to arguments collapsing Hamas, Fatah and the Palestinian Authority into the same threat. Anat answers that even the analogy with postwar Germany, if used, points toward rebuilding rather than eliminating a population. Both reject mass killing and forced displacement as answers. Her reference to approximately 4.5 million people is a figure stated in the conversation, not a verified count for everyone between the river and sea. Nor are their references to politicians’ statements legal findings about particular individuals. The practical point is to address the people who actually live there rather than imagine they will disappear.

33:28 — Fear, messianic politics and children’s finite lives

Anat argues that incremental displacement and territorial expansion serve an eternity-focused political project. Her comparison of belief structures is not an equivalence of every person’s actions; she specifically identifies Sinwar’s responsibility for a terrible massacre. Daniel asks what they can tell their children if life is continually sacrificed to an indefinite future. Anat sees political change as necessary and asks democracy protesters to confront the occupation too. They discuss how fear and popularity can spread extreme rhetoric, while remembering that public visibility does not itself establish political expertise.

39:33 — Restoring names, faces and civilian life

Anat says Palestinians have been shown mainly through a security lens, without dreams, literature, art, intellectual life or architecture. She is criticizing representation, not claiming those things are absent. She does not deny the existence of support for Hamas or people who mean harm, and explicitly condemns the massacre without justification. Her objection is to turning everyone into a faceless hostile mass. Her broad assessment of news coverage is a viewpoint rather than a comprehensive study of every report.

41:09 — Coalition-building and two underlying disputes

Daniel asks how to cooperate with people who backed judicial changes, since his own political camp cannot simply impose a future. Anat’s rough figures of 35% secular or lightly traditional people, 20% Arab citizens and around 12% Haredim are her conversational estimates, not a verified demographic classification or calculation of a coalition majority. She wants a renewed debate on religion and state, ideally separation, and a strategic decision about the territories. Her claim about all democracies separating religion and state is too broad: constitutional arrangements differ. Daniel keeps asking how to bring moderates from other political backgrounds into the process.

45:19 — Breaking with routine, and a feared future

Anat suggests stepping back from poisonous social-media exchanges. She fears a return to ordinary routines, memorial ceremonies and more armament without changing underlying policy. Her references to approximately 1,200 victims, more than 500 soldiers, more than 25,000 deaths in Gaza and 70% of homes destroyed belong to the discussion’s wartime claims; they are not verified current totals and their definitions and sources are not established here. Her imagined future of devastating retaliation is a feared scenario, not a forecast proven inevitable or a statement that any group deserves harm. Daniel asks to return from that pessimistic picture to possible hope.

48:20 — Prepare the ground instead of announcing war

Daniel worries about political processes that neglect opponents’ fears, recalling Oslo, Rabin’s assassination and the judicial struggle. These links are his interpretation, not a complete causal account of the assassination or a justification for violence. He compares a sudden policy initiative to arriving with a 200-kilogram hammer rather than a five-kilogram one: a metaphor for overwhelming force. In families too, a step experienced as a declaration of war can encourage escalation. He wants listening before unilateral shocks, without claiming every disagreement is small or that retaliation is unavoidable.

50:37 — A possible common-good camp, not a candidate endorsement

Anat sees a possible gathering around Gantz, Eisenkot, Hili Tropper and Matan Kahana that might express a wish for a common good. She explicitly says she is not a Gantz supporter. Daniel similarly distinguishes what the gathering symbolizes from confidence in an individual’s leadership. They discuss whether Haredi parties might change, but leave that as a question rather than certainty. Poll trends mentioned in the recording are historical impressions, not present electoral information. Both worry that people can exploit trauma to inflame fear and argue for limits on legitimizing extremism.

54:51 — Ratings, political visibility and a counterexample from social media

Daniel recalls working in the Knesset from 2011 to 2015 and watching incentives for provocative visibility grow. He asks Anat, then associated with the journalists’ organization, whether journalism can become more responsible. Anat offers a counterpoint to blanket condemnation of social media: bloggers and investigators with modest tools have checked facts, supplied context and challenged established journalism. Their emergence during the democracy protests matters to her. This does not make every online critic reliable or prove that technological change will automatically repair the system.

57:46 — Journalism and access to Gaza

Anat distinguishes journalism from broadcasting or serving as an organization’s spokesperson. She criticizes wartime coverage for lacking investigation, curiosity and difficult questions. Regarding military-escorted reporting in Gaza, she wants journalists to explain who permitted access, where they could go, whom they could meet and what restrictions or censorship applied. The military spokesperson’s institutional role is different from independent reporting. These are her observations about conditions at the time, not a verified statement that every report or every journalist operates in precisely the same way. Transparency about access helps the audience judge what is shown and missing.

1:00:17 — Different audiences see different wars

They contrast Hebrew-language Israeli coverage, Arabic-language coverage and international news, arguing that unequal exposure to civilian suffering affects how people understand criticism. Criticism of Israeli policy is not automatically antisemitism; that does not establish that antisemitism is absent from every reaction. Anat discusses an estimate of 25,000 deaths and an asserted 9,000 Hamas fighters, asking about the remaining 16,000. This is a comparison of historical figures cited in the discussion, not independently verified casualty accounting; subtraction does not establish the civilian or combatant status of each person. She emphasizes children, older people, families and humanitarian conditions.

1:02:05 — Will news organizations actually change?

Anat remembers previous professional self-examination after wars and a recollection of a news executive describing angry audience reactions to images from Beirut. The recollected quotation is not independently verified here. She is unsure whether institutions will learn, but values online scrutiny that makes stories and criticism visible to journalists. Daniel hopes for a reaction against polarization, mentioning a programme by Guy Rolnik; neither knows what technology might emerge. Hope is not a guarantee that the global incentives of social platforms will correct themselves.

1:04:24 — Emotion is allowed, but suffering is not a qualification

Daniel describes strong emotions, harsh words and departures in mediation and says he does not panic when feelings emerge. However, his saying that every couple fits mediation once they have suffered enough must not become a professional rule. Mediation requires voluntary, informed participation and an assessment of safety and suitability; threats, violence, coercion or harm to children may require protective, legal or clinical help rather than further suffering. A person need not exhaust themselves in court before being entitled to help, and legal proceedings can be necessary. Facts and reliable information still matter alongside emotion.

1:06:11 — Listening does not make every position legitimate

Daniel recognizes that he previously gave too little attention to other people’s genuine fears. Technical maps and written agreements alone do not address pain. Anat agrees that listening matters but warns that indiscriminate pluralism can hand the agenda to dangerous extremes. They reject treating support for rape or genocide as merely another equally legitimate panel opinion. Daniel compares this with advisers who meet separating couples at a vulnerable moment and push them into war. The point is to choose help carefully, not to reject independent legal advice or protection.

1:09:29 — Shared rules, Arab participation and a place for connecting faith

They seek basic rules anchored in common values, allowing continued argument within a shared foundation. Daniel is willing to meet people who irritate him to discover whom he can work with. Both insist that Arab citizens belong in this conversation. Anat praises Mansour Abbas’s political and personal courage as her evaluation. His religious identity also complicates their earlier criticism of messianism: faith can connect rather than divide. They call for human life over territorial supremacy and equality over ethnic superiority, without erasing differences. They close with hope after addressing painful matters; the transcript ends at 1:12:11.

Original episode and Hebrew text

Sources for historical and safety clarifications

השאר תגובה

Skip to content